What's your rating of AOTC from 1-10 (10 being the hightest and 1 the lowest)?

I saw it last night it was great it is the
best star wars movie yet man it?it?it is so so so so so so so so so great

I am going to see again and again and again!!!!!!!!!

see it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I give it a 100 out of 10

 

first time i saw it, i was a bit dissappointed on how everything turned out, so i gave it a 7. but now that i've seen it again it has improved quite a bit, so i'm giving it an 8.5. bu those romance scenes really really need a lot of work.

Boromir19, wow that's a pretty high score seeing it for the first time. i'm pleasantly surprised.

 

10 only one word can justify this rating













































































YODA

 

At the moment, I'd give it either a 7 or an 8. My opinion may change after repeat viewings, however. Yoda's fight scene was so cool it hurts.

I'm having a very hard time comparing it to all the other SW movies because it just feels so different. I felt like I was watching A.I. with Star Wars characters.

 

10 million!!! I loved it! So much action, it looked beautiful, the story was incredibly emotional, the actors were wonderful. I loved it! It's right up there with Empire for me.

 

i give aotc a 9, only empire gets a 10!!!!!

but AOTC was awsome....yoda rocks...for being what like 800years old

 

Even after being spoiled silly for the last 8 months, I give this a 10! Palpatine's subtle manipulation of Anakin and of the Senate is priceless.

 

8.5 to 9 I'll need a few more viewings to know for sure.

 

9 out of 10.

This movie totally floored me. It's right up there with ESB.

Erik

 

I'm gonna have to say 7.5 after the first viewing. The points get taken off for the terrible love story dialogue (I hate to say bad things about God, I mean lucas, but he needs to hand over all the screenwriting details next time around), and I may be the only one, but I was disappointed in John william's Score, especially the new song. I just didn't click for me.

The things that saved it (and may make cause me to reconsider after more viewings): A)Yoda is one Bad Ass MotherF****r. I mean Jesus Christ who'da thunk it and B) That scene at the end with the IMperial March as the clones get on to the transport as Palps watches with Bail getting all pissy behind him.

 

I'm going to give it an 11. It was one of those movies where you have to go to the bathroom in the first fifteen minutes and hold it for the rest of the time, sit there in agony and still can't take your eyes off the screen!

There were certain faults, but they made it fit better within the context of the other movies. I liked certain parts of the romance, but some of it was cliched. I thought Hayden's performance was a little over-the-top, but he was very effective at expressing anger, which bodes well for episode III.

 

10!!!!!


WOW!!! [face_shocked]




[face_shocked]

 

7 outta 10

There were a lot of things still not right in the Star Wars universe....It was much better than PM though...I'm gonna see it again, but initial impression goes like this...

My ranking:
Empire
ANH
ROTJ/AOTC tied
Muppet show with Mark Hamill
Ewok Adventure
Christmas special
PM

Not really...just kiddin' PM wasn't all that bad...

 

10

 

10

BEST. MOVIE. EVER.

 

6.

Too many things about this movie aggravated me upon first viewing. Perhaps upon subsequent viewings this will change.

 

11.
I thought it would be good but it was better then i thought.
Why do people complain about the romance i thought it was o.k?

 

Being objective and rating Star Wars for what it is.

9

Here is my top 10:

ESB: SE
ESB
AOTC / ANH Tied
ROTJ / ANH: SE
ROTJ: SE
"The Beginning" TPM Documentary
From Star Wars to Jedi
TPM ON DVD
Special F/X - The Making of ESB
TPM
Classic Creatures - The Making of Star Wars Tied

The Caravan of Courage...

Man, this gets too complicated

 

Well, this will proabably change after repeat viewings, but right now an 8.

 

WOW!

 

10
No Worries!!!
Yeah the some of the love dialogue was lame, forced, and the chemistry is non exsistent.
It's Supposed To Be. Anakin is trying to get Padme to give it up but she won't have it.

Love scenes didn't bother me at all and thats what i was most worried about.
The CG still awesome looking even if it looks fake.

It's either CG or Puppets take your pick.
Personally I prefer CG.

 

AOTC gets a 9 in my book. Friggin awesome. Close to on par with Empire. What ESB is better at (script), AOTC is better in action.

I don't get the problems with the dialogue. I was completely ready and willing to blast the dialogue in the love theme, but for the most part I actually thought it worked. I was even negatively influenced beforehand, and I still thought it worked.

Yoda is.......well, YODA (no better compliment!)

 

I give it an 8. I sort of want to give it a 9 after seeing the whole thing but the first half was tough to plow through.

 

I give it a 7 with ESB getting an 8 and ANH getting a 7.5. And I also have to re-rank my movies

1. ESB 8
2. ANH 7.5
3. AOTC 7
4. ROTJ 6
5. TPM 4

 

I loved AOTC and can't wait to see it again. I'd probably give it about an 8.5 to a 9. There were a few little things I didn't really care for, but overall it was great!! Its either my favorite or a very close second!