Discussion in 'Attack of the Clones' started by Obi-Gon_Jinnobi, May 16, 2002.
A very easy 9.5...leaning towards 10.
My ratings now:
2.AOTC(breathing down ESB's neck)
Hey, why not just start a poll on this?
let the people vote from 1 to 10...
I don't know which movie some of you were watching...everything in this movie rocked (the romance, action, acting, dialogue, mystery, all of it ).
Well, I didn't see that many people rate it bad. I'm seeing it on Saturday, so I'll chime in when I see it.
I just got back from seeing it again and after my first showing I said in another post that I gave it a B+/A-. After seeing it again, it gets the full 10 and an A+. i really enjoyed this movie.
K, I saw the movie at 12:01 last night, and thought it was absolutely awesome. First half hour of the movie I wasn't impressed, but soon as the war began, and the saber duels were beginning, I was amazed... and hey! Yoda, definetly, was worth seven bux.
Just got back from seeing AOTC! WOW!!! The first 30 mins or so was a bit shaky with setting up the story but the rest of the movie ROCKED!!! The Yoda/Dooku fight was incredible and made-up for any minor complaints. The arena scene with all the Jedi fighting was great too. I have to say also, that I wasn't to sure about the movie after seeing the trailer's early on but the trailer's didn't do the movie justice.
Definitely a 9 -- on first viewing.
(side note) Did anyone else see The Matrix Reloaded/Revoluion trailer before AOTC? Looked promising
I'm tired of all these haters ripping on the dialogue and love story...
It was top notch and revived star wars for me!
From the first viewing I give it a 10/10. I went with my friends to the midnight showing and it was just amazing. My mouth must have hung open the entire time.(And a jaw drop when Yoda made his fantastic entrance. I love that littel dude...) There was soooo much action to it. Great
9.5, maybe even a 10. Like many of you I was spoiled rotten so there were little things that didn't happen quite as I pictured them. But this film is truly on a par with the OT and has some of the best action sequences ever put on celluloid,er,digital camera.
And the love story was, to me, beautiful. It clicked for me, as did the Tattoine scenes. Some of the most beautiful and moving stuff to ever be in a SW film.
1) ESB (10 points)
2) ANH + ROTJ (both 9,9999999 points)
3) AOTC + ANH (both 7,9999999)
ANH - 10/10
TESB - 10/10
AOTC - 9/10
TPM - 7/10
ROJ - 6/10
I'd give it an 8.5. ESB is a 10, and it didn't match it.
It's the second best film, in my view.
Oh let's be honest...THEY ALL ROCK!!!!
I'd say 9.75. It wasnt perfect, but it was damn near close!
10 out of 10!! Star Wars is back!!
AOTC gets a 9 out of 10 from me...
ESB is a 10
10. As close to perfection as any Star Wars movie will ever get. ESB was too slow IMO. AOTC was everything i wanted in a SW movie and more!
ESB - 10/10
AOTC (need more viewings before it can beat ESB) - 9.9/10
ANH - 9.5/10
ROTJ - 8.5/10
TPM - 7.5/10
8.75 sabers out of 10. Empire is still my favorite and ANH is just slightly better than Clones, IMHO. Well, right now. I have to see Clones more and give it time to sink in.
Still, what a great movie.