Which film in IMDB's top ten does not deserve the honour?

The Dark Knight, definitely.

 

One flew over, is way over rated, so is Pulp Fiction. Yes Casablanca should be there for sure.

 

Ok I gotta wonder why Pulp Fiction is considered to be so great. I enjoyed the first scene and then the rest was rather meh.

 

I guess Tarantino isn't for everyone.

 

I look at that list and the only two movies that are truly top ten, in my opinion, are The Godfather and Schindler's List. And maybe The Godfather II. Just a sampling off the top of my head that should be ahead of the rest of the movies on the list:

Citizen Kane
Casablanca
Gone with the Wind
The Wizard of Oz
Lawrence of Arabia
The Searchers
And probably Singin' in the Rain, even though it's not my favorite.

 

You make good points.

 

TDK. I feel the movie is overrated. The one thing that keeps me watching it these days is Heath Ledger. I mostly just skip the rest

 

None of them deserve the honor IMO.

 

There are a few that I don't think deserve to be there but The Dark Knight deserves it the least, IMO. It was a good movie, just not that good.

 

The Dark Knight... It was good, yes, but it didn't move me. (I will say, however, that Ledger's performance was amazing.)

 

I think Dark Knight is getting bashed unfairly. Maybe it isn't a top 10 movie, but it is still the best superhero movie yet made, and one of the greatest thrillers in history. And I have no problem calling Ledger's performance as the Joker the best villan in film history.

 

Pulp Fiction.

Okay movie, but not in my top 100.

 

I voted, but apparently didn't say what I voted for.

I'm trying to remember and I think I said The Dark Knight. It's a wonderful film, but let it stand the test of time a bit longer before automatically putting it on the Top 10 list.