Discussion in 'Revenge of the Sith' started by DarthSapient, May 19, 2005.
do you need a love slave?
Sith rocked last night, best one yet, going to see it again in an hour and twenty minutes
This thread comes just in time.
And sometimes polls such as these defer users from creating redundant threads for a few minutes.
I voted for Sith by the way. Saw it this morning.
i vote sith.
but it will take time and the dvd to get a true feeling.
I have to say hands down... ROTS. It was outstanding.
I don't know that I can vote yet.
Revenge of the Sith all the way and this is someone who watched Star Wars for the first time way back in 1977 and never thought EBS would be outdone.
Sapient this dosen't allow us to rank ROTS among the other films. Could you maybe create a poll for each film and where it would rank? Another forum perhaps?
ANH, is still my fave. Might change after seen ROTS a second time this afternoon.
I still think it is better if u all can list the rankings of the movies in the reply like the old, locked thread.
For me : ESB/ROTS(tied for now, but I vote for ROTS here) -> ANH -> AOTC -> ROTJ -> TPM
^^^ What Patriarch156 said goes for me, too. After one viewing, I rank ROTS first, slightly ahead of ESB. I never thought ESB could ever be topped.
I saw Rots for the 2nd time today. Still blew me away, still had tears in my eyes when OB1 talks to PadmÃ©, still cheered when Vader attacks Kenobi and BOTH started. Pure magic.
EDIT: Oh, I voted for RotS of course.
After 14 to 15 years, Return Of The Jedi has been knocked off the top spot for me.
Revenge Of The Sith is my vote.
At the moment, it's clearly Sith. But I want to give it some time to wear off and a few more viewings before I vote.
At this moment in time its ROTS, but its always changing so I probably shouldn't have voted
a new hope (just look at greedo versus han solo)
Still ESB, and that will never change.
Right now, though, ROTS ranks third behind ESB and ANH, but after a few more viewings, it may make it past IV.
I'm worried I can't chose ROTS because it may lack rewatchability because it is so dark and emotionally powerful.
I'm still torn on this question.
ROTS, and I doubt my opinion will change. (unless we get more, which I have a sneaking suspicion we will...)
ROTS is my personal favorite. I can't wait for the DVD to come out later this year.