Discussion in 'Prequel Trilogy' started by Garrett Atkins, Mar 8, 2013.
Which scenes in Revenge of the Sith would have cut and why?
None. Would have added scenes. All 3 Rebellion scenes, destruction of the Jedi Order, Yoda lands on Dagobah.
And add the missing Obi-Wan and Padme scene, but I can't think of anything I would cut
I'm not sure if that scene was filmed or not. But yes add it.
Have extended Dooku duel.
Misread Wookiepedia on that scene
I hate any scene with talking battle droids. The scene in the beginning after Anakin, Obi-Wan, and R2 lands on Dooku's ship is cheapened by the talking droids. I would mute the battle droids.
I agree with lengthening the Dooku scene. I find the audiobook of the battle more enjoyable than the movie.
I would have seriously rethought the Palpatine Mace fight. I would have add some edits.
Probably cut one of the times Anakin complains about no one trusting him..
once is enough
None, the movie was perfect!
in your opinion
mine= it really wasn't
My eyes. They have seen this before.
i just imagined your avatar saying that
before slicing himself
I would reshoot everything with Anakin on it...Hayden did a terrible job. Other than that, The movie is perfect as it is.
I would have made a few scenes better, such as when windu tried to kill sidious ( what a moron ) or Anakins reason for turning to the dark side, other than that, is all good I guess.
Those are some pretty big changes.
I would cut nothing, the film is fine the way it is.
The first four words. Thumbs up.
I might shorten the Obi-Wan vs. Grievous fight if it meant Palpatine and Anakin's discussion about changes to the constitution could be reinserted, but that's about it.
I thought Spielberg's version of Obi Wan vs Grievous fight was way too long and drawn out, glad Lucas didn't go that way.
I would have cut one of the final duel scenes where Anakin and Obi-Wan are just standing in front of each other and swirling their light sabers around. It looks stupid for them to be fighting like that.
Plus the elevator scene, where they back up and find battle droids waiting inside of it. I didn't like how they were just standing that close together while swinging their light sabers like that. It seemed unrealistic.
I'm sure there's more, but I would be here all day and it would come off as nit picking, anyway.
Add the scenes with Padme, Bail, and the other senators, and record Qui-Gon's conversation with Yoda and add that.
I truly do not understand why people with this viewpoint continue to venture into a PT based board. All you're creating is hostility. Nothing constructive. Nothing.
Didn't you just reply to a RLM thread to bash RLM?
It's the PT board. Not the RLM board. There's a difference. Do you see me on YouTube bashing the RLM videos? Nope. Why? Because nothing constructive will come of it.