Discussion in 'Star Wars Saga In-Depth' started by The_Sith_Prophet, Mar 1, 2003.
I would say Anakin.
if they were put against each other i would say anakin would win... the only reason vader didn't kill luke in ANH is because of Han solo
Most definitely Anakin. Luke is a fair pilot, but he most definitely isn't one of the best, which is what Anakin basically is. The predominent reason, I think, why Luke managed to destroy the Death Star is because of the Force, not (mainly) because of his piloting skills.
It's pretty close, but Anakin seems to have the edge. Hopefully in Episode III we'll get to see a little more space combat from Anakin.
He'll accidently blow up another TF ship
I think Anakin is the better pilot. As said above Vader had Luke in the trench on the first Death Star except Han came along. In ESB he got shot down on Hoth, and in ROTJ he has to abandon his speeder. Thus far Anakin hasn't crashed.
It is hard to say because in the trench scene it would be extremely hard to dodge any laser fire in such a confined space so Luke done pretty dam good to hold off Vader until help arrived.
I would say Luke, because up to Aotc, Anakin has only been seen as a actual pilot once.
Luke for sure.
I would go with Luke.
I would say Anikin, he did take out a Driod Control Ship
It is definitely Anakin. At just 9 years old he was able to survive the space battle at Naboo. Luke wouldn't have been able to do that. He piloted the speeder at very high speeds through Coruscant and all its traffic excellently. Luke in the Battle of Hoth was shot down and he didn't have as much stuff to avoid.
When you compare them the advantage easily goes to Anakin.
Going by the movies I have to say Luke is. I mean yes Vader had him in his sights, but come on, it was Luke's 1st time flying an X-Wing. Maybe in Ep III my mind will change.
I would say both. They both have skills and they are good to rebels.
If you're talking about flying skills then I'd say Anakin(Podrace, Battle of Naboo, Coruscant Chase).
But for combat flying I'd say Luke(Battle of Yavin, Hoth, Falcon Gunner).
I bet Anakin's just as good in a fighter as he is with speeders. We just haven't really had much of a chance to see that. I'm confident Ep. III will show us that Anakin is the "best starfighter pilot in the galaxy".
- Won the pod race, which no other humans even consider competeing in.
- Accidently or not, piloted the Naboo Fighter and destroyed the Federation ship, dodging fighters, etc.
- Coruscant chase.
- Whatever else we may see in Ep3
- Single handedly picked off a variety of X-wings, etc. during the first Death Star Battle, before his wing men failed to protect him from Solo...but still managed to regain contol of his ship and escape before the DS blew up.
All we saw from Luke was destroying the DS and at the Battle of Hoth (which he was shot down in ). I think Luke is an exceptional pilot, but in the films he has never been tested like Anakin was, so he's never proven himself to be in the same league as his father.
its luke, tough wedge is better the both: he survivede the first death star, the battle of hoth and helped take down the seconed death star
I would say Anakin.
In TPM Anakin (who is the only human who can pilot a podrace, and at nine years old) who not only survives the entire three lap race, but he also won against the toughest competitor in the galaxy, Sebulba.
He may have destroyed the Trade Federation ship by accident, but considering he was only nine, he fared pretty well.
And in AOTC, Anakin seems to be a great pilot, dodging narrowly between fire torches, screeching in and out of traffic, and and so on.
Now in the OT, Luke does some amazing things as well. He survives the Trench Run and becomes one of the few people to survive the Battle of Yavin, and he rides a speeder in a heavily wooded forrest area.
He also piloted well in TESB at Hoth, but remember, he did crash, as well as crashing on Dagobah
I'd say they're both great pilots, but i think Anakin was put in more tense piloting conditions, and considering he was ten years younger than Luke during TPM, I'd say he's a better pilot.
I agree with you Aunecah.
Anakin definitely has the better piloting skills. Someone mentioned before that in ANH it was Luke's first time in an X-Wing, but in TPM it was Ani's first time in a Starfighter and he was younger. So Anakin has my vote.
Votes for Anakin: 13
Votes for Luke: 6
(I didn't count The_Fury's or Master_Scooter's votes because they were voting for both or none. )
Judging from the numbers, I would say Anakin is winning by a large margin.
Exclusively on piloting skills Wedge Antilies and Han Solo and Lando Calrissian beat them both.They don't use the Force and Annie and Luke did(Anakin use it without being aware of it and in the Battle of Naboo R2 helped a lot).Luke crashed in Dagobah,Hoth and Endor(in the trench run he was helped by Obi-Wan and Han).
Between Anikin and Luke Anakin wins-never crashed(until now)and passed by more demanding situations(Coruscant chase).
Is this a race or a dog fight?
Well, they've both done about the same amount of piloting on screen, so let's examine. With Anakin, the examples of piloting we've seen from Anakin is Naboo, where he crashed a ship after doing very little in space, and then on Corsucant, which was some good piloting. (Pod's lack the three dimisional aspect necessary to qualify it as piloting). With Luke, we see him survive an intense space battle where experienced vets did not, and fought in the battle of Hoth while recovering from frost bite. I'll go with Luke, though probably not much better than Anakin.
I'm going with luke. Luke usually was taking on superior numbers with the Rebel's outdated equipment, with questionable reliability.
Imagine if a group of guys took Vietnam era fighters up against modern F-16's and won. Even if they took a bit of a beating, you need superior skills to overcome that technical defecit.