Who would have made a better Anakin?

We are finally on the same page

No were not. You see if you take this one character out of AOTC. AOTC for me becomes a movie with out any flaws. Again the character has such a small part that and is such a small flaw. It does not ever hurt the film.

 

If Epi 2 hadn't started production and nobody was cast and I had asked this question most of you would be singing a different tune and you know it.

That's a rather unfair statement. Nobody here had even heard about Hayden before he was cast in AOTC, so it's obvious he wouldn't be any of our choices right off, because nobody had heard of him before then.

 

i love Hayden Christenson's portrayal Anakin.. or maybe i just love Hayden Christenson.. either way.. i dont think anyone could have made a better Anakin

 

"No were not"

Yes we are because you know that Lucas will not change Epi 3 no matter what how we feel about Hayden or Jar Jar thus keeping the movie *FLAWED*.

No matter how small it is a flaw is a flaw but I argee with that I still love AOTC

 

Edit: You know I'm done with this thread. It makes my blood boil and that not a good thing so I'm leaving this thread.

 

I love how you keep on talking for everyone here. It's really quite amusing.

Cometgreen

 

Yeah, newbies do have a tendency to do that. Until someone sets them straight.

 

I say...Sam Jackson should've been Anakin.

One one condition, he has to yell SUCKA!! when he kills somebody.

 

Your right DarthSal,

Us *newbie* have to stick together,buddy.

 

Uh, no. Us "newbies" do not stick together. And do not call me your buddy, umkay.

Go back to arguing with those who disagree with your choices for Anakin Skywalker.

 

I've never seen anyone Champion the four feather's/Knights tale guy like du365 does....are you the president of the Heath Ledger Fan club?? If you're going to pick another Anakin, please choose one who doesn't have a perm in all his movies.

 

"Uh, no. Us "newbies" do not stick together. And do not call me your buddy, umkay.

Go back to arguing with those who disagree with your choices for Anakin Skywalker"


What are you talking about?


How can you call me a newb when I join before you, newbie.Get your MATH straight and another thing just because I don't like Hayden acting doesn't make me a bad guy- *I* just don't like Hayden acting in this movie that all.

I've read some of your post and you not exactly setting the world on fire,either Darthsal.


It's just a movie.

 

How can you call me a newb when I join before you, newbie.Get your MATH straight and another thing just because I don't like Hayden acting doesn't make me a bad guy- *I* just don't like Hayden acting in this movie that all.

Nobody ever said you were a bad-guy. The majority simply disagrees with your opinion that Hayden is bad. There's no "bad-guy" in this debate.

It's just a movie.

Exactly, please remember that in the future

 

Well, this thread's gone utterly nowhere.

It was a really loaded topic title anyway. What not try something like "Would you have preferred a different Anakin?" or something.

Then you might get more discussion, rather than just annoy the fans of Hayden right off the bat.