Went to a BBQ with one of my most disgruntled Star Wars fans and the inevitable Episode 3 discussion came up. I was so sure that he would have positive things to say, but he replied with "It was ok...I don't know if I really liked it. The dialogue was just awful." Now granted, I'll give him several of the exchanges between Anakin and Padme. But beyond that, I felt that some of the writing was the strongest of the series. We chatted some more and he never agreed with my positive points. Oh well, some people will never be happy with it. Anyways, just curious, how many bashers in your life see ROTS as redemption and how many are more bitter than ever?