Discussion in 'Star Wars And Film Music' started by Carnotaur3, Aug 13, 2005.
Certainly not. Just pointing out the exception to your statement.
Your Imperial March was good. This was odd.
It adds continuity to the PT. This cue just needs to appear in ESB and ROTJ and it's all good!
Well, if "continuity" means nothing more than "repetition," then I don't like it.
...Yeah, the tracking is pretty bad when you hear it like KM did it. Or someone.
i actually think the escape from naboo music should be used LESS. it should be completely replaced in the podrace scene, and rerecorded for 2 and 3, then added to 4. but it doesn't go anywhere in 5 or 6.
i'd also like to hear more use of what seems like the rebel theme, used in episode 6 when they arrive at the death star. i'd like to hear it in episode 4. and maybe slowed and worked into the rebellion scenes in episode 3 (which need to be put in the film)
Please could anyone repost the Ben's Hut and Duel on Death Star? I would love to see it man...
Replaced in the podrace scene? That's no problem, because there was original music recorded for that scene, dropped in favor of "Escape from Naboo."
Escape from Naboo does not belong in Ep.IV. Re-recordings for 2 and 3 would be ok, I guess.
the song fits in that scene, better than the music that's currently there.
plus, for the first time we see the streaking stars thing, that scene seems quite boring with the current music. "escape from naboo" would add energy to it.
No. Just no.
WORD! I agree completely. Especially about the Imperial theme from ANH! Highly underrated indeed. I like The Imperial March, but I never took it to be the best theme in the saga as many do. To each thier own, but I think it's overrated simply because of the character it's mostly associated with.
Hearing a solo oboe play the ANH Imp theme gives me more chills than a brass heavy 'bad guy march'.
fear of change. how sad.
yeah its scary people fear change to something, when this change it could be for the good of it, like latinos become the majority and whites becoming mininority , buti'l before i get off topic and evoke response, i personally wouldn't change ANH score at all, but that doesn't mean its necessarily a bad thing to change it.More like add on to the score than take away.
there are very few things in the score that should be removed. but the music during the escape from mos eisley is veery boring, and needs to go. at least most of it, you'll notice in my edit i left the music used to represent the star destroyers.
and if they'd include both the theatrical version, and a perfected version, of the saga on the dvds, the change fearers would have nothing to complain about.
but they'd complain anyway, it's what they do.
Yeah, you're right. It's more exciting and it adds continuity to the saga. Lets add Battle of the Heroes to every saber fight, with DotF undertones. I wanna hear Across the Star replace the Han and Leia theme. Screw it, lets replace the 20 year old music with TPM music. It's way better.
ah yes. one extreme or another. your fear has made you angry and irrational
Nope, and I'll be relieved in knowing that you aren't Lucas and what you say or do to A New Hope does not effect my DVD.
He has a different opinion than you (one I share)and that makes him some sort of "change fearer"?
And Imperial Cruiser Pursuit is not boring...
TtBk, The Millennium Falcon/Imperial Cruiser Pursuit
Guys, guys, really!
TO EACH THIER OWN!!
sorry, did'nt mean to butt in.
fearing change, even if it's for the better, is not an opinion.
Let's discuss the topic.
The music that's in there is fine, but I would like more of it, because the movie is a bit too quiet for my taste when I compare it to the other episodes.
Silence - it sounds
This is not the case, but I don't fear it. I don't like it.
oh come on. you can't even hear the music in that scene. it's drowned out by the sound effects.
the problem is that you view anything from the evil prequels infecting the sacred originals as blasphemy
Not true. I just don't think it would flow as well. I liked hearing Anakin's theme in the Hut, and if Williams were up to it, new music for the ANH duel. But other than that...I really wouldn't want to see music replace orignial music.