After reading a bit of a suggestion and seeing some common things going on in various threads in the PT section, I've conferred with heels and have decided to make this thread Now, I'm going to make it very clear - this thread is for criticizing the PT, not for bashing Criticism = I dislike this and here's why, and I'd prefer it this way Bashing = This is stupid Even worse = This is stupid and you're stupid if you like it/This isn't stupid and you're stupid for not liking it The key here is not just to list the things you dislike. Share why you feel as you do and if you wish, how you would have done it yourself. The last part is not to be confused with our other thread for PT rewrites - if you want to talk about how you'd do the PT in general, head over there. If it's about a specific criticism and/or a way you'd prefer it, it belongs here I'll say right off the bat that this thread has potential to prosper in either direction, so it'll have a firm eye kept on it. If we feel the thread has gone too far off track and the trolling goes on even after warnings, then this will be locked So in short - criticisms, not complaints. And as anywhere else, films, not fans. If someone disagrees with you, it is within their right, and neither should attack the other in any way With that in mind - enjoy!