<<<I think we are saying he's inconsistent.>>> Personally, I don't see Midis as inconsistent, against Campbell, or an OT contradiction. I see 'em simply as a lousy addition to this saga that cheapens the accomplishment of mastering the Force. Just as something as ridiculous as Vader being a watered-down Anakin clone wouldn't contradict the OT, Campbell, or anything else. It'd simply cheapen the Vader character a great deal. That's all. That's enough.