Discussion in 'Revenge of the Sith' started by DarthSapient, Apr 14, 2004.
I created this poll for the user waheennay. Now you can get a Yes or No.
Numero uno(voting at least-heh), and yes ofcourse this is going to be the best SW movie ever... it better be!
The entire Saga hangs in the balance with this one, just like Anakin over the cliff......
Do or Die folks, DO or Die....
George, Fandom is in your hands.
If everything goes according to plan, then yes.
I think that for some people it will be... however, there will be people who will HATE it. The fact that the dialogue is no less campy than the other prequels and that the acting is pretty much on par with TPM means that fanboys will hate it.
However, the fact that it is full of action and a much darker movie than the other five might make it both a fan favorite and regular viewer favorite.
If it's like the real life version of the Clone War cartoons, then 'Yes'. It has all of the goods storywise that we wondered about in the OT.
What -_-_-_-_-_- said!
I love the PT, love it, but IMO it still ain't as good as the OT (and won't be after III). EPIII will be damn good, but it won't be the best.
That will always remain The Holiday Special.
It has been the best SW movie since the official site mentioned that Ian McDiarmid will have a major role in it, having lots of screentime.
This made it a fact: Eps.III is already the best!
I voted no, not because I dont' think Episode 3 won't be great, but I dont' think ANH can be topped.
It will no doubt be the greatest of the prequel films. Whether or not it's the greatest of all the SW movies, I wouldn't even venture a guess. Ian could improve it greatly.
"I created this poll for the user waheennay. Now you can get a Yes or No."
I'm sure he's very very happy. But we can still posts our opinions whether he likes it or not.
I agree. The best of the Prequel Trilogy... and maybe better than Return of the Jedi... but I don't think it will be able to top ESB or ANH.
Yeah Yeah Yeah
I was tempted to be very positive and say yes...however ESB is tough to beat.
Therefore...nay I say.
It's a bit early to tell, methinks. It looks very promising, and I'm quite enthused about the film, but it's still too soon to call.
My votes YES but thats mainly because I would like to think Episode 3 will be the best Star Wars film. It has the potencial to be but it will have to be the longest film, have more depth with the characters and tie up all the major loose ends in order for it too happen.
I agree, Roland. And by the way, it's molten metal on Coruscant. You're so wrong.
All the ingredients are there for it to be the best SW movie by far, its all in the execution.
I hated to vote NO but I just cannot see it surpassing ESB. Best of the Prequel Trilogy, I would expect it will be.
For me it probably will be. Even though all the movies are my favorites, I don't hold the existing episodes in such a high regard that they can't be beaten - and I think the only movie that could ever beat them, for me at least, is Episode III.
Nope, sorry I think ESB already holds that title.