I think big time not. LOTR: FOTR FX almost reached perfection, and I think that ILM and their obssession with doing everything CGI now could have spoiled the movie. The FX team of LOTR used CGI only when asked for it, and the realism of the movie was impressive. ILM would probably use CGI to do all the orcs, the hobbits in plenty of occasions, and most of the Middle-Earth scenarios. The result would have been something like the poor work shown in movies like Return of the Mummy and Harry Potter (I still canÂ´t stand their troll). Your thoughts?