X vs. Y - A New Game!

Well, not new, but revisited

One person puts up two items, and the next person must decide which is better, which would win, etc. And then that person puts up two more items to be debated by the next person.

Example:
Person #1
X-Wing or A-Wing?

---

Person #2
X-Wing!

Pink Twi'Lek or Green Twi'Lek?[/i]





So here we go....

OT or PT?

 

OT!

Leia...or...Padme?

 

I'm going w/ nostalgia: Leia

Comics or Cartoons?

 

Ooo...tough one. On the one hand there's a lot of comics that have sucked, but some that are cool. On the other, we had "Ewoks" and "Droids"...but they were later redeemed by the Clone Wars...

Cartoons.

Episode 2 Anakin vs. Episode 4 Darth Vader?

 

Episode 4 DV - Episode 2 Ani was just too annoying (yeah he was supposed to be a little, but it might have over the top a time or two )

Episode 3 Obi or Episode 4 Obi?

 

Episode 3!!! He's way cool! (and hot)

Wampa vs. Rancor

 

Wampa. Yeah, a Rancor would probably kill a Wampa...but the Wampa is the one that messed Luke up...He completely spanked the Rancor with no marks to show for it.


Episode 3 Jedi Star Fighter or OT X-Wing?

 

The ETA-2 (Ep. 3 Starfighter) definitely. Smaller profile...bigger engines...bigger guns.

Only trick -- you have to have Force powers in order to pilot it, or the lack of shields, armor, and the squirrely controls will make you dead. LOL. Only thing that comes close is the A-Wing.

Endor or Yavin?

Edit: Got my Episode numbers wrong.

 

Endor... I couldn't hack the jungles of Yavin, and love great big forests to play in

Jedi or Citizen?

 

Endor, fuzzy ewoks any day.

Episode 3 Anikan or Episode 6 Luke?

 

Citizen. With lots of money. And connections with the Black Sun. Jedis don't get to have any fun.

Ep. 6 Luke. I can't stand Anakin.

Ep. 2 Clones or Ep. 3 Clones?

 

Ep III Clones. Certainly greater in number by this time and they have had a chance to be broken in.
And who couldn't dig those nifty new outfits!

OK, Salacious Crumb or Bib Fortuna?

 

Salacious Crumb - poke ur eyes out

Jango or Boba?

 

Hmmmm...Jango. Boba was just a clone without formal Mandalorian training, and he didn't know how to use his jetpack. Although, Jango seemed to have the same jetpack problems on Kamino. LOL.

Thrawn or Isard?

 

Thrawn. The man is the best military mind in all of SW. I get chills thinking of how great a leader he was.


obi and anakin VS Dooku in AOTC or ROTS?

 

AOTC. The ROTS one was sorta...anti-climactic. And they tried to squeeze in something called "acting" into the fight, too. LOL.

Green or blue?

 

Green - It casts better shadows


2 handed or single handed saber fighting?

 

ROFL.

One handed -- looks better and moves faster on screen.

Blue Twi'lek or Green Twi'lek?

 

single for quick strikes and it keeps my options open.



han shoots first or greedo shoots first?

 

Han shoots first. I must diagree with the Boba vs Jango thing. Boba was much more feared throughout the galaxy. He was also much cooler back in the OT.

Original Trilogy vs. New Trilogy

 

NT because the fights are more intense


anakin or vader

 

Vader. Anakin is a cry baby


Battle of hoth or the battle of geonosis

 

wow...are we really out of stuff already that we have to have 2 repeats on the first page? ouch...

Battle of Geonosis...more lightsaber fun.


AT-AT or AT-ST?

 

AT-ST's are faster

TIE fighter or V-wing

 

ATAT, it is just way to cool.

Space Battle at the Beginning of Episode 3 or the Space Battle at the end of Episode 6. Its a Trap, Its a Trap!!!!!