halibut posted:A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual.
Moylesy posted:halibut posted:A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual. There's a difference between criticizing a movie because it has taken a major character or plotpoint out of an established work of art but making a fuss because the CGI team got the wrong shade of purple for the supporting robot's helmet is just nit-picking.
Darth_Paddy_666 posted: Utter rubbish, no film DESERVES to be treated like that, sit back and ENJOY the film for what it is!
DarthArsenal6 posted:Moylesy posted:halibut posted:A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual. There's a difference between criticizing a movie because it has taken a major character or plotpoint out of an established work of art but making a fuss because the CGI team got the wrong shade of purple for the supporting robot's helmet is just nit-picking. Its what Halibutt said you paid for it you can do what you like You donlt have to read it or listern to them.
Moylesy posted:DarthArsenal6 posted:Moylesy posted:[quote=halibut]A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual. There's a difference between criticizing a movie because it has taken a major character or plotpoint out of an established work of art but making a fuss because the CGI team got the wrong shade of purple for the supporting robot's helmet is just nit-picking. Its what Halibutt said you paid for it you can do what you like You donlt have to read it or listern to them.
DarthArsenal6 posted:Moylesy posted:[quote=halibut]A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual. There's a difference between criticizing a movie because it has taken a major character or plotpoint out of an established work of art but making a fuss because the CGI team got the wrong shade of purple for the supporting robot's helmet is just nit-picking.
Moylesy posted:[quote=halibut]A film is a piece of artwork. Maybe "deserved" is not quite the right word, but if people pay money to see said artwork, then they certainly have the RIGHT to talk about it, dissect it, criticize it, or pretty much anything they want. Some people like to do this (me included), others don't. That's fine, it's the choice of the individual.
DarthArsenal6 posted: Darth_Paddy_666 posted: Utter rubbish, no film DESERVES to be treated like that, sit back and ENJOY the film for what it is! so is "shut up and take it" that's utter rubbish too. If you brought a product and it say whats it says but does not perform, would you except it ?
Darth_Paddy_666 posted: I pay for a film I get a film (does what it says on the tin!), it's what YOU choose to do with it that defines whether it works or not and I prefer to watch a film for the films sake, IF I see something glaringly obvious I MAY watch the film a second time for scientific dissection HOWEVER if I enjoyed the film I couldn't give a rats behind if they got something wrong!
Spike2002 posted:Still ain't seen it. Got it ordered on DVD though. *avoids spoilers*
DarthArsenal6 posted:Darth_Paddy_666 posted: I pay for a film I get a film (does what it says on the tin!), it's what YOU choose to do with it that defines whether it works or not and I prefer to watch a film for the films sake, IF I see something glaringly obvious I MAY watch the film a second time for scientific dissection HOWEVER if I enjoyed the film I couldn't give a rats behind if they got something wrong! Good for you.. Glad to here that Just for the record: if you like it, you like it, does not bother me in the slightest but moaning about other people post simiply they critising something is just a little odd. If you don't like like you don't have to take part. Getting all stress with your capitals and exlaimation marks doesn't help. Its a forum people are going to discuss and debate over it, and whatever they critise is not really an issue, is it Geeezz ....so move along
SithLordDarthRichie posted:Interesting system, I have not and will not buy a DVD of a movie I haven't seen incase I don't like it. I'll always rent it first then get it if I liike it (or these days I'll watch it a few times at work and then decide). But each to one's own I guess.
