Are the Jedi Council Forums a place for fans and praise only?

See the above. It's not what you post, it's how you post.

Make cogent, reasoned arguments and we can have a discussion like adults.

Pop into a thread and post "Ahsoka suXz! If you don't agree with me you're a butt-hurt fanboy!", and don't be surprised when people are not favourably inclined towards you.
--------------------------


this sounds like you are talking to Anakinfan directly:

in fact your whole post does,

She doesn't post "Ahsoka sux, anyone who disagrees with me is hurt fan boy"

granted I don't follow her around and read her every post, but from what threads I do read in which she has posted Anakinfan is NOT the type of poster you describe,

she backs her opinion up with a point.


Anyhoooo if you're talking about users in general who says "Ahsoka sux" what is it to you if they so think it? she's a fictional character who can't read the boards, you don't need to retaliate by coming to her defense, she isn't going to thank you or put you on her watch users list.

If people want to say a character sucks then let them, if they don't back up their argument with an intelligent reason and it bugs you, ignore them,

 

You are correct.

If you want, I'll go back and quote you specific examples of where she's done just that.

 

If you want, I'll go back and quote you specific examples of where she's done just that.
------------

no you're alright thanks, just saying in my own experiance she's fair in her views and puts forth reasons.



if someone doesn't like a fictional character isn't that their business?

you say that it isn't the fact they dislike a character it's the way they say it,

so to you as a fan, what would be a good example to say you don't like Ahsoka, Obi-Wan, Cad Bane, etc?

 

The thing is, you can be a responsible poster (I even agreed with you on a point recently)...but then you turn right around and pop off with condescending crap like:

If you have a lot of people telling you to look to your posting style, maybe you should, rather than come back with more snarks and more "Who? Me?" fake innocence.

 

Someone said my name?

 

Alright, cheers! x