Full Series Grade the Episode 4.10: "Jedi Night" (Spoilers Allowed)

Kanan’s death already gets it up there. The music was amazing

10/10

 

Gave it an 8/10. A very good, memorable episode.

 

Whole episode was great. I enjoyed it being told from Caleb's perspective to show how far he has come since season 1. He knew exactly what was going to happen and he pulled it off so perfectly to find victory in defeat and leave a strong legacy behind in Ezra.

I just don't see any reason to nitpick it, it would detract from the awesome, raw emotional impact of Caleb's heroic sacrifice. 10/10 for me.

 

Loved it. I always believed Kanan (And Ezra) should die, and this gave Kanan the end he truly deserved.
Plus, loopy Hera is the best Hera.
10/10

 

NO Star Wars death has made me cry like this... not in 40 years of fandom.

 

10.

SW, right now with the fabulous RO out there, a GREAT looking Solo movie on its way, a superb sequel trilogy more than half done, and other movies (Rian J & Weiss/Benioff) SW is again (other than my family), my life!

Loving every minute of it.

 

9/10
Great episode. I was surprised at how much Kanan's death affected me emotionally.

 

9/10

This was one of my favorite episodes to date. It really did a good job of tying Rebels into the movie's story quite well.

 

Have to give it a 9/10. Only reason it isn't a perfect 10 is because I thought there was too much foreshadowing going on during the episode. They played the foreshadowing into the story but it was still foreshadowing.

 

5/10 because for me it was a suicide. He was just waiting the whole episode to die and I did not like it. They could fly away, there was time, he could work with Ezra to push them away, instead he ran straight into the fire. And for me it was just... sloppy writing. Kanan needed to go, so let's kill him in a beautiful explosion.
The reason I didn't gave even lower grade was absolutely amazing "drunk" Hera.

 

If he knew he was going to die anyway, why not sacrifice yourself to save the ones you love?

 

But why... because wolves told him so?
When the death is more important than life? We win by surviving, to quote his own words. So Kanan lost and it was quite OOC for me unfortunately.

Because he didn't have to save them. They could all easily save themselves.

 

How do you know they would've survived the explosion if he didn't suppress it at that moment?

 

Because I'be been watching this show for over three years there were many much more closed calls.
And the way it was animated... he had time to run into the fire, why not to jump, shout Sabine go! and push with Ezra to help?

So yeah for me it was bad and his foreshadowing made it even worse.

 

There really is no pleasing some people and really that is ok because everyone has, and is entirely entitled to there own opinions. However - it was not bad writing/storytelling, cheap, an easy way out or poor delivery. It was exceptional writing and great entertainment, and more importantly someone's vision of a storyline in how THEY wanted to tell it.

Those that don't like it or agree with it, just as in the deaths of Padme, Boba Fett, Han, Luke, Admiral Ackbar etc......are fans that feel something towards those characters, a connection to their fictitious lives if you like. They don't like it and complain because their stories do not turn out the way THEY as fans/viewers wanted/envisioned. Those people let themselves down by saying its terribly poor viewing or storytelling, or worse, not necessary. The writers and creators of this story (their vision) felt it necessary, and that's all that matters really.

 

Lol this is right up there with "only Sith deal in absolutes / "chancellor palpatine is evil"

 

Ok I may be out of the loop on this one, but when did Ackbar die?

 

TLJ, in the slowest chase sequence ever shown on film.

 

I worded that poorly, but surely you get where I'm coming from. There are MANY, many works of literature, fiction, movie's TV shows that are very well made, with great stories and well written, that I just do not care for, do not like some of the decisions made by the writers/directors and disagree with storylines, but that does not make them bad.

 

Ok I forgot that scene.

 

To be honest mate I would just ignore that guy's comments, he keeps coming back to this forum to troll despite hating the show.

 

In this case I was not hating the show but simply showing up the funny side of a slightly contradictory statement.
Also I don't hate the show. I don't think it's very good (it could've been though in jmo) but I certainly don't hate it. Its just a cartoon at the end of the day.