Saga Here is my unorthodox Star Wars opinion: change my mind!

I read that as you were saying KB for a moment...I was like "what version of Skeleton Crew did you watch? She was on the of the best characters"

 

I personally think that it's code for Luke doesn't act like a Sigma, thus he sucks. Same with Anakin and Ben.

 

but to be fair, Kylo did literally throw temper tantrums



Was the intent to make Kylo look threatening and dangerous? Well it didn't, it made him comically look like a petulant man child.


I kinda agree about Luke though, and I guess if I was being truly fair, Anakin too...to some extent.

 

I think that they were trying to be funny and blew it. Vader and Sidious were intimidating with only a bare minimum of effort to be direct. They missed that with Kylo.

 

Can you imagine Kylo looking for power converters and whinging about the harvest? He would be even more soon....lol but pausing laser bolts in mid air is way cool

 

It's also maybe fair to say the Skywalker bloodline is a tempestuous at best family... Psychotic at worst... maybe Luke is the balance between his past In Anakin and his future blood, kylo..hotheads the lot of them

 

Anakin just complained as anyone who feels entitled would. His true anger surfaces when the fear of loss gives way to anger and hate. As Vader, he just intimidates you until he exerts his authority. Luke was more of a teenager in ANH, which is typical behavior of someone who lacks focus and discipline. In TESB, it's impatience. With Ben, it's just petulant anger towards his parents.

 

I would add unjustified to that.

 

The problem is that his issues are petty compared with his uncle and grandfather, which just makes him into a weak character. At least Jacen had a reason to turn in the old EU.

 

Maybe not so unpopular opinion, but Jacen Solo/Darth Caedus made the better Solo turned to the Dark Side with more plausible development and ending than Ben/Kylo.

 

They should stop announcing so many SW projects and just shadow drop them like the looming Oblivion remake/remaster

 

I think Star Wars as a franchise should have ended a long time ago from what i have seen the new generations dont care much about the franchise the people who watch Star Wars content the most are nostalgic fans Star Wars should have ended in 2005 or 2012 or 2019

I like the adult and mature tone of Andor but i dont know if that is the direction the franchise should take especially for the mainstream public who are used to a lighter tone in Star Wars Andor is the best product Disney has ever made they should fix the Sequels by giving the director of Andor a show
.

 

I know you are probably joking, but I don't understand why movie studios don't just do this.

Just a drop a trailer on everyone a couple of months before release. Let things be fresh in peoples minds and enjoy the buzz.

 

I don't like the Mon Mothma dancing at the wedding music.

 

To be fair Jacen had way more time to be developed as a character.

Sent from my SM-A716V using Tapatalk

 

I saw a clip...without context, and thought it was a great tribute to David Lynch....

I now understand it within context...and thought....what a great tribute to David Lynch.

 

I think it’s great I to would

Spoiler

get drunk if I knew one of my greatest allies was about to murder my childhood friend

 

But they do need it, it's their cover story. It's what Anakin tells Padmé and it's what Palpatine tells the Senate. The Jedi will take control of the Senate to ensure a peaceful transition as it is, so this is their way to spin things to suit themselves.

Whatever late editing took place, either way, that moment is still needed to explain their justification.

No, Anakin wouldn't think it was BS. Again, what Sith Lord wouldn't want immortality?
Anakin can rest assured that if it is indeed attainable, teaming up with Palpatine is as safe a bet as any because he wants it too. Palpatine wouldn't have gone through all that trouble if he didn't think he & Anakin had a shot at attaining it.
Anakin may not have proof of it's attainability but he does have unprecedented potential in the Force, and Palpatine has gotten him to think finding this power is his destiny.

And no, Anakin isn't going to have an erratic outburst at this moment. He sees why Palpatine did it this way, it was dirty but necessary to break down his defenses. And he's hyper-focused on finding this power to save Padmé so he's going to do whatever it takes, including maintaining his composure, to see this through to the end.


And no, Anakin can't ask to find the power now, then kill the Jedi afterwards, for at least three very big reasons.

1. The Jedi will be coming to get them any minute.
2. Palpatine needs this leverage to get him to help him kill the Jedi.
3. Last but not least, when Palpatine says Anakin needs to kill the Jedi to grow in dark side power, he believes it because he knows first hand from killing the Tuskens that committing dark acts gives you a power boost. He believes with good enough evidence that he won't be powerful enough to attain the spell unless he does this.

And as far as talking with Padme's doctors, I think it's clear Anakin is afraid Padme's death is something science & medicine can't prevent, hence his obsession with finding a magic power to stop it.

And if he wants to save Padmé (from his perceived threat), it's not that he's giving Palpatine all the cards, Palpatine has them all to begin with. Anakin has to play along. As Palpatine is the only one who knows where to even begin looking for this power.

It's not so much walking away from Palpatine that Anakin needed to do... moreso, first and foremost, it was mastering his fears, that would have been his way of avoiding this mess. Until he does that, his fears are controlling his actions, and he's at the mercy of them, and Palpatine who has the cards.


And they didn't have Anakin spy on Palpatine despite him being a suspicious character, it's Because he was a suspicious character. And this being war they felt justified in it.

How long have the Jedi sensed the dark side surrounding the Chancellor? Well, I'd say the moment Mace says so. Why then? Because it's minutes before everything goes down. He's just sent Anakin to tell Palpatine Grevious has been killed, thus ending the war, and now... It's end-game time.
Lucas said it's like the Jedi were walking through a fog. And in a fog you can start to make things out as they get closer.

 

I can't take Star Wars Rebels seriously again after watching Andor it seems like a fairy tale compared to Andor even though they coexist in the same universe and give Tony Gilroy another show please it would be interesting to see a New Republic show with this director also make Darth Revan Canon in the New Star Wars Live Action Universe