Sorry, but I disagree. Heck, even Lucas disagrees: "Dialogue has never been my strong point, and so I talked to Willard and Gloria and asked them to do a quick dialogue polish....They did about thirty percent of the dialogue" So, for his masterpiece, the original Star Wars, Lucas felt the dialogue was important enough, and recognized that it needed polishing. Secondly, the OT is probably the most quoted film series in the history of cinema. So, while you and your friends may laugh out loud, although the OT might not feature the greatest dialogue put to the screen, it is a fact, that it is certainly features some of the most memorable dialogue in movie history. While you are of course entitled to believe the PT features superior dialogue, I think most would disagree. I know I do, and I think the fact, that the PT is rarely quoted speaks volumes.