I kind of put TPM in the same category as ROTJ. It had a few amazing scenes but was plagued with a bunch of silliness. The Darth Maul duel and ROTJ throne room scenes are two of the best scenes in Star Wars history. But the same movies also had fart jokes, Jar Jar, bad acting, cute Ewoks beating Stormtroopers with rocks, the Jabba muppet show, etc... Both TPM and ROTJ could have been absolutely epic but Lucas ruined them somewhat trying to sell toys and sell out to little kids. Regarding your Anakin quote. I think the worst Anakin is the Episode 1 Anakin followed by Episode 2 Anakin. Both were pretty awful. Episode 3 was the best Anakin but still not the Anakin we wanted to see.