The Mandalorian Luke Skywalker (Spoilers)

It's a reference to Schitts Creek, using wine label/types as a comparison to sexual preference -- he's into the wine not the label/type. I was trying to be clever hoping the image would explain my gist and it looks like it didn't land -- my apologies.

I'm just happy to see more of Luke and while I love MH, I don't really care how the character Luke is portrayed.

 

#FreetheShamook

 

From StarWars.com regarding The Book of Boba Fett Chapter 6:

 

I love how the temple looks like the temples on Ahch-To!

Could it be that Luke has already been there? I mean we know from the BFII campaign how he found the compass and this Episode is certainly set after the game campagin.

 

When Ahsoka tells Luke hè reminds her of his father, she means she sees in him someone who questions the status quo and doesn’t accept certain dogma’s. This is much like how Anakin was questioning some inconsistent behaviours of the Jedi. She tells him to trust his instincts and this foreshadows in my opinion the great journey this master will make. To avoid attachment and external stimuli monks place themselves largely outside of the real world in reclusion. In comparison the Jedi acted more like Marshalls trying to keep the peace in the Galaxy. They had a time where they exerted a lot of influence on politics and society. Maybe a possible romance between Luke and Mara will learn him that it has as much value TO HAVE LOVED and LOST than to have never loved at all. I hope he will create a new Jedi school where one can find balance while engaging in the world. Inspired by Ahsoka’s words hè offers Grogu a choice, mirroring probably his own doubts about which direction to go. I think both choices were equally worthy, but in the end Grogu followed his heart. In my opinion the wise decision but the alternative was also good. As Grogu symbolises the creative and destructive power of nature for me, hè is the representation of the green man. I think the current teachings would have led him to one of both extremes. Either becoming the next yoda or falling to the darkside. A balanced path for him is better. I only hope Luke with the help of Ahsoka can alter the insane storyline of the last Jedi.

 

I knew it.

 

So we have rumors now of a post-ST trilogy that would focus on a new Jedi Order and possibly trying to avoid the mistakes of Luke's Order/the previous Jedi Order.

Meanwhile, there's also the possibility of a Luke Jedi Academy series, and we see now that he's Detachment Luke, which means that the two series could potentially work together to critique the idea of detachment.

While I love this possibility, it is regrettable that Luke once again will be thrown under the space bus, so to speak, but at least if they go this way it will be easier for me to accept if we end up with a strong critique of the nihilism inherent to this extreme version of the Jedi (this critique also applies to any religion, e.g., Buddhism, that suggests there is something inherently destructive about human love and connection--specifically romantic love and even familial love).

Still if they go this way it will be interesting to see how they handle Luke and Ben. I'm thinking that he doesn't alter the attachment rules for Ben, and this is one of the things that helps to drive Ben nuts--being unable to spend significant time with his parents, and obviously we know that Ben is interested in women due to his interest in Rey, so this approach could work pretty well.

I also hope that they work in the knowledge that Yoda gleamed during S6 of The Clone Wars -- that the Jedi's fear of the darkside allowed it to grow within them unchecked, since they denied its existence in them. Ultimately the prequel Jedi were dominated by fear, fear of the darkside, and also fear of attachment.

Fast forward to Rey's Jedi Order, where she and members like Grogu have no problem with attachments and teach their members to live in healthy emotional balance with others rather than in toxic separation from them.

One of the more amusing aspects of the Prequel Jedi way is that their attachment policy is literally based on the slippery slope fallacy.

 

That sounds dreadful: loser!Luke, poor misunderstood Benny and saint!Rey of the can-do-no-wrong variety.

 

It is dreadful but at least I would understand why Luke became a failure -- he followed the Prequel Jedi way.

That's at least a reason for his behavior when Ben falls, a reason we didn't have before now that we understand Luke becomes an emotional cripple due to the detachment rules.

You know, he becomes the kind of weird adult who asks a baby to consider never seeing his father again.

 

I don’t want to understand why he becomes a cowardly failure - I jump off the story way before this "continuity". And having my two most hated characters in SW benefit from it just adds more insult to injury.

 

Ok.

 

I'd rather that conduct be left in Star Wars history past. I like having 'clean' versions of episodes and movies now that haven't been tampered with.

 

I cant wait for more jedi, Luke, Rey and Grogu.

 

I have never seen anyone being this weird adult.

Also, he explains to Grogu that if he chooses the Jedi Way, he might never see Din Djarin again.

Luke is absolutely right in saying that. If Grogu agrees to stay as his student, he needs to know what he might be giving up.

 

To have both paths right now would be infeasible since Din's life is one full of danger and there's no telling if he would die of old age or simply perish in combat. It's not like Han or Leia, who live in relative time of peace and thus Luke could afford to see his friends and family again. But even, Luke's journey to reestablish the Jedi Order has seen him in relative isolation, symbolic with R2-D2 no longer present with C-3PO despite the two being an iconic pair.

 

Since there's 50 pages of this thread, I skimmed but did not see an idea they had mentiones this about the Respeecher dialogue.
Whether James Earl Jones gives them permission or not I was thinking couldnt they use the James Earl Jones bible read that he did to create Vader voice stuff?
Just think of the huge vocabary of individual words they can use and tweak with that....

 

Who owns that recording?

 

Ironically, Darth Vader would be the voice that makes perfect sense to use a Respeecher since, after all, that voice is in-universe produced by a machine.

 

Hey mods time to add the Kenobi tag. Man I can’t wait

 

If you turn up the volume, you can hear Luke say "Yippie"

 

He also says "I LOVE SAND!".

 

"I'll try sitting on this desert igloo and making believe I'm flying something. That's a good trick."