Scummy's Review Thread Review Thread

[link=http://boards.theforce.net/your_jedi_council_community/b10008/27752832/p1/?5]Andalite-Bandit's sandwich reviews![/link]

I love sandwiches, and I love Andalite-Bandit's posts, combined it should be a killer thread!

. . . Or so I thought.

It seems this thread is all style, and no substance. In fact, he made us click his thread and spend our time there, but neglected to actually include a review! He teased us by telling us he'd review two sandwiches, both the spicy Italian and the grilled cheese sandwich! It's too good to be true, I thought!

And it was.

Neither review is given in the opening post, and neither has been written since. If he had given one of these reviews, and withheld the other, I'd have given him at the very least an average score, but to tease us on both! Well, it's just taking the consumers for granted.

Mr. Bandit, the consumers are not to be teased, if you withhold service we will move on!

2.5/10.

[hl=green]Scummy[/hl]

 

This review thread sucks.

 

I think this is the first review thread that actually reviews something.

 

[hl=green]Scummy[/hl]

 

I think this review thread kicks ass.

 

The poster above me sucks.

 

You suck.

 

Can we get a review of the suckage?

 

Next up, [link=http://boards.theforce.net/your_jedi_council_community/b10008/27752318/p1/?57]Jacen and Flare blog about/rate the JCers[/link].

This thread is slightly less of a disappointment than the last one I reviewed, their reviews initially appear overly harsh and inconsistent, but I realized by the second one this is more of a roasting thread than anything else, and I began to appreciate it, and even begin to look forward to my own roast - if my popularity permits it, which I doubt.

Flare and Jacen's teamwork is a bit sketchy at times, with Flare overshadowing his parter, but none-the-less with the piles of review threads I'm sifting through the buddy routine is at the very least a breath of fresh air.

Most importantly though, they're consistent. They've reviewed several JCCers so far, and are continuing to do so. This is important because a lot of review threads are posting one or two and then stopping, so this is a good sign.

7.8/10

[hl=green]Scummy[/hl]

 

Thank you for taking the time to review our thread Scummy. Unlike some other people I won't mention (JoinTheSchwarz, ApolloSmileGirl), I can take a little bit of criticism and learn from it so I can bring you a better JC experience.

 

Don't do the same as those you review though Scummy!!!

 

This thread is quite informative. I do agree with your assessment of the rating thread.

 

you really should have posted this in "dave's review thread review thread review thread".

 

can you review your own thread?

 

I was too euphoric to do anything that complex.

 

Scummy, will you marry me?

 

Is that . . . legal?

[hl=green]Scummy[/hl]

 

NO! cuz I'm already married -
Be that as it may, You are just too funny!

 

i need to know how good these review threads that keep popping up are.

 

scummy is really dropping the ball.

 

revolutionariessemen