Shaak Ti - Who kills who

Master I suggest you get hyperspace because there they actually show GG kill her. she doesnt die the way you said she did.

Grievous says this: "Shaak Ti,your lightsaber seems a little battle-worn. It will need considerable cleaning, but it will do the job."
There's a sharp intake of air from Shaak Ti as she arches her back. Grievous has stabbed her through the heart. Her body slumps and Anakin and Obi-Wan turn grim.


grievous kills her. And she doesnt fight back just takes it thru the chest and dies. alot like quigon jinn died by the hands of Maul.

 

I suggest you finish reading the article. It clearly states this caused the opening battle scene to drag out and the re-shot her death. Techincally she dies by GG's hand, but in the novel and final version of filming she gets killed by Vader. A reason it was cut from the film was it made no sense for the Clones to be wiping out the Jedi while she's sitting there meditating.

 

She doesn't die in the cartoon. Grievous captures her and wraps her up in this kinda kinky electro-rope stuff and Mace saves her.

 

well, a picture speaks a million words. And that picture of GG killing her proves it.


I dont see anakin killing her in any pics. Pictures are official, novels are all EU stuff.



Edit:

She doesn't die in the cartoon. Grievous captures her and wraps her up in this kinda kinky electro-rope stuff and Mace saves her.

hey pooj how are ya?, no offence but you know cartoons are EU and are not canon.

 

hehehe...that would be pretty funny.

Shaak thinking: "I sense something.....wrong..."

Jedi Padawan's screaming in the distance: "Help us Shaak Ti.......HELP US!!!! There are too many!!!!!"

Shaak: "hmmm, I still sense something but I cannot put a finger on what it is"

Padawans: "PLEEEEEASE...NO....NOOOOOOO.....why are you clones doing this?!!!!!!!!! HELP US SHAAK TI!!!!!!!!"

Shaak: "hmm, I still sense something....I am sitting here meditating and there are.....these....feelings...of......death and pain....I wonder what it could be...."

a lightsaber ignites behind Shaak and Shaak opens her eyes

Shaak thinks: "Uh Oh...I think the Temple may be under atta.....AHHHHHHHGH"

Anakin cuts her to doom.

 

Well, I think the cartoons are good to go by. Maybe not every single detail has to add up, but Shaak Ti does survive the cartoon, and Lucas had two different deaths planned for her in Episode III, so I believe it's safe to assume that she survives past the cartoons.

 

The security hologram clearly shows Shaak Ti being killed by Ani

 

Doubtful. got a screen capture? pic or something?

 

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA...yea, play the game Lego Star Wars and you see Anakin cut Shaak Ti's head off her chest and then her chest off her legs on the hologram Obi and Yoda are watching......it was very funny.

 

The security hologram clearly shows Shaak Ti being killed by Ani

Ani is seen killing Cin Drallig, Bene and Whie in the security footage.

The scene that was shot during pick-ups featured Shaak-Ti being killed by Ani while she was meditating in her private quarters when Ani and the troops raid the Temple.
The scene was cut from the movie.

 

Ani is seen killing Cin Drallig, Bene and Whie in the security footage.

exactly! after watching ROTS 10 times now I dont recall seeing shaak getting killed by anakin.

Cin dralling, I hear is going to be in the deleted scenes DVD. In the game he is ok, nothing special.

 

Did you even READ the article?:

During the pick-up shoot at Shepperton, Shoshan was scheduled for a single scene of shooting. She traveled from Australia to London to brave the makeup process again. The scene was eerily familiar, but instead of sitting on the floor, she sat on one of the thick disc-like ottomans Jedi have in their private quarters (Knoll would refer to them as big wheels of cheese). The slatted window-shade casts a film noir shadow on her. Hayden Christensen, wearing his dark hood up, steps into frame. "What is it, Skywalker?" asks Shoshan. There's no answer, other than a stab in the back.

It took many takes to satisfy Lucas, something that was profoundly felt by much of the crew since it was the last day of a very busy two weeks worth of shooting. Much of that morning of September 3, 2004 was dedicated to Shaak Ti's demise. But for all that effort, it was cut from the movie (it did make it into the novel, though).

Ultimately, this murder raised more questions, and was incongruous with the preceding shots of Anakin marching up the steps of the Jedi Temple with a column of clone troopers. Surely troopers weren't waiting patiently at the door while Anakin killed Shaak Ti, but if they were storming the temple, why was Shaak Ti meditating? How did she not know that her brethren were dying just outside her door? Ultimately, it didn't work cinematically, but that's what editing is for.

 

Oy Vey!

 

You might also want to check the photo on page one.

[image=http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v252/wildezc/VaderandShaakTi.jpg]

 

Well this is nice.
I thought this thread was dead and buried a long time ago.

 

This scene was cut, I hope they put it in the DVD. SSIntimidater posted that it was cut because it didnt make sense, which I kind of agree with but leaving it in wouldnt of ruined the Jedi temple raid scene anyway. It was ruined to begin with. It lacked good music, Anakin did nothing, and you caught a 3 second glimpse of clones killing Jedi. Later you get to see a tiny 2 second hologram of Anakin parrying a lightsaber blade...wow so amazing! The only decent part was they youngling scene. Lucas should have expanded the temple raid instead of wasting all that time in the begining on those R2D2 jokes.

 

HAYDEN stops him and IAN throws him out the window, a fall
which no PARTIALLY ELECTROCUTED JEDI CAPABLE OF
SUPER-JUMPING could possibly survive.

HAYDEN CHRISTENSEN
What have I done?
(pause)
I submit myself to your will, Ian.

IAN MCDIARMID
That was fast. Well, now that you
have taken a single, somewhat
justifiable step toward the Dark
Side, there's no turning back. Go
kill all of the Jedi in the temple,
including the children.

HAYDEN CHRISTENSEN
Right, go kill the children. Got it.

IAN MCDIARMID
Well, kill everyone, not just--

HAYDEN CHRISTENSEN
(leaving)
On my way to kill all of the
children now! Whee!

He DOES. The CLONE TROOPERS kill most of the adult Jedi,
while the challenging task of murdering children can only be
undertaken by the DARK LORD OF THE SITH.

http://ter.air0day.com/?script=revengeofthesith

That about sums up the whole scene. Would have been much more dramatic to SEE the Temple destruction.

 

turkey the pic you directed me to shows GG killing her. no sign of anakin there.



Sorry dude, i must not have the full picture available, it showns her on her knee's with her eyes closed in a dark room. I could'nt see anybody else in the room, just her, it looked like the room yoda talks to anakin in. Sorry for any confusion.

 

BTW wasn't Felucia (?) Shaak Ti's homeworld? If so why was everyone's favorite hot Jedi there instead of Shaak Ti. It would make sense to me that you'd want to protect your system.

 

While editing both versions of her end leaves Shaak Ti's demise in the air for fans, I agree that it was the right decision. I'm pretty sure no general audience member was in the theater crying "Wait, where's Shaak Ti!?"

 

I don't think it made sense for General Grievous to kill Shaak Ti, as it was initially supposed to be done. The opening crawl clearly states that "Two Jedi knights" were dispatched, so suddenly there's three and it's just Shaak Ti alone? I dunno, just my take.

 

Well,
My 7 year old daughter (Who makes me buy her every single Shaak-Ti item at Toys R Us) and I both exclaimed shortly after leaving the theater, "Where the heck was Shaak-Ti??)
Since then, I have found Shaak-Ti in the Jedi Council scene, but I digress.....

 

She's in a jedi council scene? What part in the movie? I have seen it a few times but have yet to see her. She's pretty cool. It's weird how one charicter can be latched onto by the fans so collectivly. like Boba-fett. I bet if lucas knew how the fans would react he would not have cut her scene out.

 

Shaak Ti and Stass Allie were seen in the holographic council that Yoda looks at on Kashyyyk.

[image=http://www.starwars.com/databank/character/tarfful/img/movie_bg.jpg]

Shaak (3rd from the right) and Stass (second from the right) are the only two council members that aren't seen in person during the council scenes.

Oddly, there is someone else sitting to the right of Stass (even though Stass should be on the end). I think that may be Plo seated in the wrong seat.

 

If Lucas based his editing on fan reactions the movie would be 8 hours long and one giant mishmash of randomness. It would make less sense than ever!