Discussions Skill tierlist

S Tier -
Grandmaster Luke
Yoda
Sidious
Darth Vader

A+ tier -

Kyle Katarn
Count Dooku
Mace Windu
General grievous (Legends)
Anakin Skywalker (ROTS)

A tier -

Shaak ti
Kit Fisto
Luke Skywalker (ROTJ)
Obi-wan Kenobi (ROTS)
Plo Koon
Darth Maul (TPM)
Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)

B+ tier -

Quinlon Vos
Ki-Adi-Mundi
An'ya Kuro
Oppo Rancisis
Sora Bulq
Depa Bilabba
Darth Maul (post TPM)
Asajj Ventress

B tier-

Qui Gon Jinn
Sasee Tinn
Kylo Ren
Savage Opress
Tholme
Aalya Secura
Eeth Koth
Adi Gallia
Obi-wan Kenobi (AOTC)
Anakin Skywalker (AOTC)
Agen Kolar
Luminara Unduli
General Grevious (TCW)
Even Piell
Bultar Swan
Jaden Korr
A'sharad Hett
Ahsoka Tano (Season 7)



C+ tier -

The Grand Inquisitor
Barriss Offee
Ahsoka (Season 1-5)
Stasis Allie

C tier -

Cal Kestis
Rey
Obi-wan Kenobi (TPM)

D+ tier -

Trilla
Ninth sister
Kanan Jarrus

D tier -

Fifth Brother
Eighth Brother
Seventh Sister

F+ tier -

Ezra Bridger

F tier -

Finn

Honorable mentions:

Cin Drallig (ROTS Game both console and handheld) - A+
Serra Keto (ROTS Game) - B
Darth Caedus - A
Jaiana Solo fel - A+
Mara Jade Skywalker - A+
Darth Plagueis - A
Anakin Solo - B
Ben Skywalker- C+
Kyp Durron - A+
Corran Horn - B+
Qu Rahn - B
Jerec - B+
Galen Marek - A (May change later)
Aurra Sing - C+
Ferus Olin - C+
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

My rules for this list;

1. This is based on overall skill in the five following categories;
A. Physical capabilities (including force augmentation)
B. Lightsaber dueling (Offensive and Defensive modus operandi)
C. Force Abilities, how they use them, and how it could be applied in battle.
D. Typical Strategy and tactics in battle
E. Weaponry

Addendum:

Just because someone is lower-tier doesn't mean that they can't consistently beat someone in a higher tier. This is mainly due to their skillset being a direct counter to the others I.E

Ventress vs. Kit Fisto, and Obi-wan Kenobi (ROTS) vs. Anakin Skywalker (ROTS)

I would like to hear any suggestions and additions that I need to make to this list, as I'm trying to make it as comprehensive as possible. I'm pulling from every continuity here.

 

What about some of the Jedi and sith of the old republic such as Revan, Malak, Bastilla, Satale Shan,Exar Kun


BY The Way welcome too the forums and Good Post I really Like this one.

 

Haha, thanks @Jedi Knight88!

As for the people you mentioned I haven't made my way to do full research on them yet. However, my hypothesis for these chracters would be:

Revan - S Tier
Malak - A+ Tier
Bastilla - B+ Tier
Satale Shan - A+ Tier
Exar Kun - Somewhere between S and A Tier, this guy and Bastilla I need to do alot more research on.

How do you feel about my placement of both versions of Maul?

 

Looks good as for your placements of both versions of maul I would have put post tpm maul I would have put him stronger than tpm maul because he was defeated by a padawan even though it was obi-wan he still lacked proper training in use of the lightsaber and the force.While post tpm maul managed to Kill Pre Visla the holder of the darksaber and leader of the Death watch visla was also a master of many more weapons including the rocket on his jetpack which he fired at maul and maul used the force to evade it all while still holding a big advantage during the fight.he also manged to create his own crime syndicate and get his brother savage opress as his apprentice and spy against the sepritists ha was only defeated when palpatine himself had to step in and take him down because he saw him as a rival.Yet he still survived into the movie Solo.
But that is just how I feel about it and feel free to ask me any questions on any other people you need help with I may Not always be right on it but I am Happy to try

 

Nice list, though I will say if there is a placement I'd nitpick it would be Darth Vader's. Many sources(including those originating from Lucas) assert Vader is a relatively unpolished duelist and is below the Jedi from the PT era in skill. That's not to say he's bad, but I think being placed with the best in the mythos is a bit too high

Bernael Edit: Thread locked by moderator due to inactivity. Should you desire the thread reactivated please contact Sinrebirth, darthbernael, or Bardan_Jusik.