Rogue One The Official "List Your Complaints about Rogue One" Discussion Thread

I really like the realism of there being varied force beliefs, orders, practices, etc. Makes the world that much more interesting.

 

I'm thankful that they didn't make Chirrut a Jedi for the same reason they didn't make Lyra Erso a Jedi (which was the original idea). Because Rogue One isn't a story about the Jedi. And honestly if they had just made Chirrut a Jedi, I don't think he would be as interesting.

 

Here's a minor nitpick that I have... Admiral Raddus died off-screen. It doesn't bother me too much, but I just kinda wish that we had actually seen his death instead of it having to be confirmed behind-the-scenes.

 

This thread should not have even reached 2 pages!

 

Don't worry. 90% of it is people defending Rogue One from criticism. Which is completely outside the bounds of the thread. But Rogue One is so good that the criticisms of it can't sustain a thread for very long. So the thread needed help from the movie's fans.

 

The example used to illustrate the concept of "conflict of interest" in this year's edition of the Oxford English dictionary is "@TCF-1138 and @EHT moderating a thread about criticisms of Rogue One."

 

They say that if it's a quiet night, sometimes, when you look up at the stars, if you listen carefully, you can hear a distant voice, defiantly calling out, "I say we fight!"

 

AWESOME until the ending. The same goes for Solo.

 

I agree. Awesome until the ending when it became even awesomer.

 

Cool. But I meant the ending for both were too fast or confusing.

 

Just messing with you. But now that you elaborated on it, what was “too fast” or “confusing” about the ending of Rogue One?

 

Vader should've killed those Rebel troopers a lot, lot slower, plus he could've shouted "I want that disk, it contains the plans for the Death Star!"

 

His death was better off screen, trust me. Without going into too much detail, Palpatine had calamari marinara for dinner that night.

 

Ah, so that's why Palpatine didn't appear in A New Hope... Raddus had his revenge.

 

I'm so disappointed in this Rogue One film that Lucasfilm shot it on digital video instead of real film. In 8 years they'll be able to remaster episodes 7-9 to 8k resolution, but Rogue One will forever be stuck in only 4k.

 

Who cares, it looks fantastic.

 

You forgot yes.