ST Rank your 3 favorite scenes from each of the 3 x ST films

And no listing of opening logos, scrolls, or credits!

List your 3 favorite scenes from each of the 3 ST films:

TFA:
1.
2.
3

TLJ:
1.
2.
3

TROS:
1.
2.
3.

I’ll go first.

TFA:
1. Intro to Rey on Jakku.
2. Interrogation scene.
3. Rey force pulling the saber from the snow.

TLJ:
1. Hand touch hut scene.
2. Killing of Snoke.
3. Luke on Crait.

TROS:
1. Exegol. All of it.
2. Ben Solo killing Kylo Ren after his talk with Han.
3. Renewed Luke on Ahch-To with young Luke & Leia flashback and Luke lifting the X-Wing.

 

I’ll play, but just with TFA.

1. Finn’s intro on Jakku in the village, panicking and refusing to kill innocents;
2. Rey’s intro scavenging and then loading her speeder;
3. The lightsaber trio, even though in hindsight I do not think Rey should have won definitively. Overall I think it’s really well done besides that.

 

TFA:
1. Kylo interrogates Rey
2. Han confronts Kylo
3. Kylo vs Finn and Rey

TLJ:
1. Luke on Crait
2. Snoke's throne room
3. The Holdo maneuver

TROS:
1. The kiss
2. Ben remembers Han
3. Rey vs Kylo on Kef Bir

 

I had to make some tough cuts.

 

TFA:
1. Han reaches out to his son
2. Meeting Rey
3. Meeting Luke

TLJ:
1. Luke on Crait
2. Poe attacks the dreadnaught.
3. Rey and Kylo Ren in the thrown room of Snoke.

TROS:
1. Rey faces down Palpatine with all the Jedi behind her.
2. Han reaches out to his son
3. Luke and Leia Spirts

 

Poe attacking the Dreadnought is an inspired and original choice @Jedi_Sith_Smuggler_Droid

I hadn’t considered that one as one of the TLJ’s best scenes but in retrospect it really does develop nicely and there’s some cool visual scale differences and flying maneuvers. Plus Captain Cannady is a blast. Pardon the pun.

 

The Force Awakens

1. Rey and Finn finding the Millennium Falcon and escaping Jakku.
2. Kylo Ren and Rey lightsaber battle on Starkiller Base
3. Rey scavenging the Star Destroyer remains

The Last Jedi

1. Snoke Throne Room scene
2. Force connection (in Hut) on Ach-To between Kylo Ren and Rey
3. Luke Skywalker saving the Resistance on Crait

The Rise of Skywalker

1. Rey and Ben Solo on Exegol (everything about it)
2. Han Solo and Ben Solo on the Death Star ruins
3. Rey leading the Resistance to Exegol in Luke Skywalker's (Red Five) T-65 X-Wing.

 

Thanks!

Cannady is great. That snarl he does as the destruction hits the bridge. He might be my favorite officer in all of these movies other than Tarkin. I also find Poe's diversion tactics with General Hugs truly funny. And the hard less Poe learns as most of the Resistance ships are destroyed is touching.

We also see the set up for Palpatine's killer Star Destoryers in The Rise of Skywalker. (And again on Crait with the door buster based on Death Star Tech.)

 

TFA
1. The entire Rey introduction sequence.
2. Kylo - I will finish what you started sequence.
3. Rey arriving on Achto.

TLJ
1. All the force bond moments between Rey and Kylo
2. Throne room fight
3. Luke vs Kylo on crait

TROS
1. Ben and Rey Force bond that leads into fight vs KOR and Sith trooper guards.
2. Zorri Bliss arriving and saying Space trash after shooting the canon.
3. Ben and Rey kiss

 

Rey's introduction
TR-8R.
Rey on Ahch Tu.

 

As much as I hate the First Order i would love to watch Captain Cannady in a successful war battle barking out orders.

 

TFA:
1. Rey sliding down the dune with the Star Destroyer in the background
2. Han / Kylo showdown
3. Jedi steps

TLJ:
1. Throne room fight
2. Rey cutting the stone and wrecking the caretakers wheelbarrow
3. End credits

TROS:
1. Take off of the Tantive IV (visually great)
2. Babu Frik / Zorii in the cockpit
3. Rey destroying the transporter in the desert

 

TFA:
(1) Han reminiscing on the Falcon.
(2) Han and Leia banter at the Resistance base.
(3) Rey offering Luke his father’s saber (though this was ruined by the next film).

TLJ:

(1) Luke and Leia reunite.
(2) Ren kills Snoke.
(3) Leia drifting through space.

TROS:

(1) “Rey Skywalker”
(2) “You’re a Palpatine.”
(3) “And I... am all the Jedi.”

 

I anticipated you. See OP.

 

TFA:
1. Lor San Tekka's final stand.
2. Rey and Finn reunites on Starkiller Base.
3. Han Solo's appeal to his son.

TLJ:
1. Rey's first lesson.
2. Luke's farewell to Leia.
3. Luke confronts Kylo Ren.

TROS:
1. Kylo Ren finds Darth Sidious.
2. Rey meets Nambi Ghima.
3. Poe mourns Leia.

 

Ok. I'll change 3. credits to 3. Fading out to the stars

 

I enjoy that Nambi Ghima scene also but just curious... what is it about the scene that you enjoy most?

 

The thirty seconds where Luke first sees Artoo, when he's genuinely happy to see him, in TLJ.
After that, I got nothing. Because every moment I might have liked was destroyed by the ending of TFA. Now, if we're listing worst scenes....

 

TFA;
1. Luke (maybe not in my top 3 now the saga is done but back in 2015 this was the moment I waited the whole film for)
2. Han confronts Kylo Ren
3. Finn and Poe's escape

TLJ;
1. Luke and Leia reunion through to Luke's death
2. Throne room scene
3. The first lesson

TROS;
1. Ben Solo on Exegol
2. Han and Ben
3. Tie between Luke raising the X-wing and Lando arriving with the fleet

 

TFA:
1. Rey / Kylo duel under the snow
2. "The Force, the Jedi, it's all true..."
3. Finding Luke

TLJ:
1. Luke on Crait
2. Battle of Crait
3. Lesson One

TROS:
1. Kylo / Rey duel in the sea
2. Kylo / Han scene
3. Luke on Ahch-To

 

TFA:
1. Kylo vs Rey.
2. Han’s death.
3. Snoke’s giant holo.

TLJ:
1. Snoke’s throne room.
2. Luke’s death.
3. The Holdo manoeuvre.

TRoS:

1. The first scene on Exogol.
2. Lando arriving with the armada.
3. Rey vs Palpatine.

 

I'll play, even though I haven't seen TROS.

TFA
1: Rey finding Luke / cliffhanger
2: Finn and Poe meeting
3: Rey's intro - scavenging / sliding down dune / riding the speeder

TLJ
1: Luke with R2 on the Falcon

 

I think it's because the scene provides a nice break in an otherwise fast-paced movie; It's just Rey interacting with someone, who isn't important to the overall story. It's a very subtle form of world building, and it also gives Rey a time to shine in a different way compared to the rest of the movie. To be fair, I do not enjoy how the scene basically functions as a way to highlight her lack of a "family name", but I can live with that.

 

TFA
1. Lightsaber Duel with Kylo Ren
2. The opening shot
3. Snoke (he was genuinely kind of creepy in this one)

TLJ
1. Luke on Crait
2. Luke on Ach-To
3. Pretty much anything Luke

TROS
1. Anakin's voice
2. Rey finding Vader's helmet
3. Lightsaber Duel on remains of Death Star 2

 

TFA
1. Rey’s introduction. I like the melody of Rey’s theme
2. Kylo’s lightsaber twirling / Force freeze move on Rey in the Forest. Probably the coolest shot of Kylo in the entire trilogy
3. Kylo interrogates Rey

TLJ
1. Luke drinking alien [MODified: Disallowed Word] milk
2. Luke / Rey in the tree scene
3. Any scene involving Kylo trolling Rey via the Force Dyad

TROS
1. Babu Frik
2. Kylo snatches the necklace from Rey’s neck
3. Yay - Ben Solo