"Academy Awards" of the Star Wars saga

Only list one winner for each award!

My choices:

Best Special Effects: TPM
Best Editing: TESB
Best Score: TESB
Best Supporting Actress: Shelagh Fraser in ANH
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid in ROTS
Best Actress: Natalie Portman in TPM
Best Actor: Mark Hammil in TESB
Best Screenplay: ANH
Best Director: Irvin Kershner TESB
and
Best Picture: TESB

 

Explain what it is that you want us to do please.

 

Sorry if I was unclear!

List your own personal choice for the winner of each "Academy Award" listed above.

Your pool of movies to choose from are the six films making up the saga. Choose only one winner per award.

 

I cheated a little, but it's still all Academy Awards and Star Wars related stuff.

Best Special Effects: TPM
Best Makeup: RotJ
Best Editing: ESB
Best Score: RotS
Best Original Musical: ESB
Best Cinematography: TPM
Best Supporting Actress: Pernilla August in TPM
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid in ROTS
Best Actress: Carrie Fisher in ANH
Best Actor: Harrison Ford in ANH
Best Screenplay: ESB
Best Director: Irvin Kershner ESB
The Irving G. Thalberg Memorial Award: George Lucas
Best Animated Feature: upcoming Clone Wars
Best Documentary Feature: Empire of Dreams
Best Picture: RotS

 

Best Special Effects: ROTS
Best Editing: ANH
Best Score: TESB
Best Supporting Actress: Rose Byrne in AOTC
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid in ROTS
Best Actress: Carrie Fisher in ANH
Best Actor: Harrison Ford in TESB
Best Screenplay: TESB
Best Director: Irvin Kershner TESB
and
Best Picture: TESB

 

Best Special Effects: Revenge of the Sith
Best Editing: The Empire Strikes Back
Best Score: Revenge of the Sith
Best Supporting Actress: Pernilla August (TPM)
Best Supporting Actor: Harrison Ford (TESB)
Best Actress: Carrie Fisher (ANH)
Best Actor: Ewan McGregor (ROTS)
Best Screenplay: The Empire Strikes Back
Best Director: Irvin Kershner (TESB)
Best Picture: The Empire Strikes Back

 

Shouldn't this category be "ONLY Supporting Actress?" The other women people have mentioned had two lines at most.

 

you're right, it was tough!

I chose Aunt Beru - she had next to no lines, but that's kind of the reason I chose her - she had barely any lines and yet she made an impression on me

 

Best Special Effects: Revenge of the Sith
Best Makeup: Revenge of the Sith
Best Cinematography: Revenge of the Sith
Best Editing: A New Hope
Best Score: A New Hope
Best Supporting Actress: Pernilla August (TPM)
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid (ROTS)
Best Actress: Natalie Portman (TPM)
Best Actor: Hayden Christensen (ROTS)
Best Documentary Feature: "The Beginning" (TPM DVD)
Best Screenplay: Revenge of the Sith
Best Director: George Lucas (ROTS)
Best Picture: Revenge of the Sith

 

Best Special Effects: ROTS
Best Makeup: ROTJ
Best Cinematography: TPM
Best Editing: ANH
Best Score: ANH
Best Supporting Actress: Sheila Fraser(ANH)
Best Supporting Actor: Jimmy Smits(ROTS)
Best Actress: Carrie Fisher(ANH)
Best Actor: Alec Guiness(ANH)
Best Documentary Feature: From SW to Jedi the making of a Saga
Best Screenplay: ESB
Best Director: Irvin Kershner(ESB)
Best Picture:ESB

 

Interesting...the only 2 films (so far) to receive Best Picture awards are TESB and ROTS...

 

Best Special Effects: ROTS
Best Makeup: ROTJ
Best Cinematography: ESB
Best Editing: ANH
Best Score: ESB
Best Supporting Actress: Pernilla August TPM.
Best Supporting Actor: Liam Neeson TPM
Best Actress: Natalie Portman(ROTS)
Best Actor: Alec Guiness(ANH)
Best Screenplay: ESB
Best Director: Irvin Kershner(ESB)
Best Picture:ESB

 

Best Special Effects: The Phantom Menace
Best Makeup: Return Of The Jedi
Best Cinematography: ESB
Best Editing: The Empire Strike's Back
Best Score: The Empire Strike's Back
Best Supporting Actress: Natalie Portman (ROTS)
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid (ROTS)
Best Actress: Carrie Fisher (ESB)
Best Actor: Harrison Ford (ESB)
Best Screenplay: The Empire Strike's Back
Best Director: Irvin Kershner(ESB)
Best Picture: A New Hope

 

Best Special Effects: AOTC
Best Editing: ROTS
Best Score: TPM
Best Supporting Actress: Rose Byrne in AOTC
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid in ROTS
Best Actress: Natalie Portman in AOTC
Best Actor: Hayden Christiansen in ROTS
Best Screenplay: AOTC
Best Director: George Lucas AOTC
Best Picture: AOTC

 

Best Special Effects:ANH
Best Editing:ROTJ
Best Score:TESB
Best Supporting Actress:Natalie Portman in AOTC
Best Supporting Actor: Ian McDiarmid in ROTS
Best Actress: Natalie Portman in ROTS
Best Actor:Ewan McGregor ROTS
Best Screenplay:TESB
Best Director: George Lucas ANH
Best Picture:ROTS

 

Vote tally so far...

Special Effects
In the lead: ROTS with 5 votes
Runners-up: TPM 3, AOTC 1, ANH 1

Best Editing
In the lead: TIE - TESB and ANH with 4 votes each
Runners-up: ROTS 1, ROTJ 1

Best Score
In the lead: TESB with 5 votes
Runners-up: ROTS 2, ANH 2, TPM 1

Best Supprting Actress
In the lead: Pernilla August in TPM with 4 votes
Runners-up: Shelagh F. ANH 2, Rose B. AOTC 2, Natalie P. ROTS 1, Natalie P. AOTC 1

Best Supprting Actor
In the lead: Ian McD. in ROTS with 7 votes
Runners-up: Liam Neeson TPM 1, Jimmy S. ROTS 1, Harrison F. TESB 1

Best Actress
In the lead: Carrie Fisher in ANH with 4 votes
Runners-up: Natalie P. TPM 2, Natalie P. ROTS 2, Natalie P. AOTC 1, Carrie F. TESB 1

Best Actor
In the lead: TIE - Harrison F. in TESB, Hayden C. in ROTS, Ewan M. in ROTS, and Alec G. in ANH with 2 votes each
Runners-up: Mark H. TESB 1, Harrison Ford ANH 1

Best Screenplay
In the lead: TESB with 7 votes
Runners-up: ROTS 1, AOTC 1, ANH 1

Best Director
In the lead: Irvin K. TESB with 7 votes
Runners-up: GL ROTS 1, GL AOTC 1, GL ANH 1

Best Picture
In the lead: TESB with 5 votes
Runners-up: ROTS 3, AOTC 1, ANH 1

 

Special Effects
Overall: RotS
Taking when the film was made into account: ANH

Best Editing
The Empire Strikes Back

Best Score
The Empire Strikes Back


Best Supprting Actress
Pernilla August: The Phantom Menace

Best Supprting Actor
Harrison Ford: The Empire Strikes Back

Best Actress
Carrie Fisher: A New Hope

Best Actor
Mark Hamill: Return of the Jedi

Best Screenplay
The Empire Strikes Back


Best Director
Irvin Kershner: The Empire Strikes Back

Best Picture
The Empire Strikes Back