main
side
curve
  1. In Memory of LAJ_FETT: Please share your remembrances and condolences HERE

Converting Geoffrey Mandel's 1978 Imperator-class into RPG stats.

Discussion in 'Archive: Games: RPG & Miniatures' started by RaptorRage, Dec 1, 2001.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. RaptorRage

    RaptorRage Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 17, 2001
    After looking closely at these blueprints by Geofrey Mandel made in 1978, I was wondering how to go about converting this to RPG stats, or at least how to determine what the designations used for weaponry and carried craft would mean in moden Star Wars terminology. I'll type out the stats from the third blueprint as its a bit difficult to read from the image.

    --------------------------------------------
    Imperator-class Star Destroyer

    Dimensions:
    Length Overall- 486.5 meters
    Width Overall- 297.5 meters
    Height Overall- 147.5 meters
    Main Hull Height Overall- 70.7 meters
    Standard Ceiling Height- 3.05 meters

    Basic Armament:
    [142] 38 cm Heavy Laser Batteries
    [26] 19 cm Light Laser Batteries
    [32] 60 mm Laser Cannons
    [6] forward mounted Missile Silos launching [20] ten megaton and [100] five megaton Space to Ground Missiles
    [8] rear mounted Minelayers deploying [40] two megaton Proximity Mines

    Standard Armor Plating- 75 cm

    Performance:
    Cruising Velocity- .4 Light
    Max Velocity- .65 Light
    Endurance at Max Velocity- 480 Hours
    Max Hyperspace Jump- 250 Parsecs

    Number of Antimatter Engines- 3
    Number of Hyperdrive Engines- 4

    Standard Crew Deployment:
    Officers- 25
    Vessel Maintenance- 112
    Gun Crews- 138
    Field Commanders- 18
    Stormtroopers- 280
    Fighter Crews- 117
    Utility Droids- 60
    Total-750

    Standard Hangar Compliment:
    TIE Fighters- 48
    TIE Assault Craft- 24
    TIE Boarding Craft- 6
    --------------------------------------------
    Some questions regarding converting some of his non standard terminology into standard terms:

    -Would the "38 cm. Heavy Laser Batteries" and "19 cm. Light Laser Batteries" be considered Turbolasers or regular Lasers? If they are Turboalsers, would they be Heavy and regular Turbolasers, or is there a Light Turbolaser that is in any RPG reference? Also, whould they really be considered multi-barreled batteries, or single-barreled guns, as the blueprints seem to show only single barreled guns to denote these weapons.

    -Would the "60 mm Laser Canons" refer to anti-starfighter lasers similar to those used on the Lancer-class frigate?

    -Would the "Missile Silos" be considered Concussion Missile, Proton Torpedo or Multipurpose Launchers? Conversely would the apparent nuclear "Space to Ground Missiles" be nukes, or rather Consussion Missiles, Proton Torpedoes or some other modern SW warhead?

    -Would the 24 "TIE Assault Craft" be considered TIE Bombers?

    -Would the 6 "TIE Boarding Craft" be the type using a TIE Bomber hull that has the warhead launcher hollowed out that holds six troopers?

    Note that this class is being considered seperate from the standard 1.6km Star Destroyer commonly referred to as the Imperial-class. I do not agree with those that use these blueprints to argue the "correct" name based on Earth naval naming conventions for the ISD is Imperator-class.



    Geoffrey Mandel's 1978 blueprints of the Imperator-class, as referenced in Curtis Saxton's Star Wars Technical Commentaries: Star Destroyers webpage

    [image=http://www.theforce.net/swtc/Pix/kdy/blueisd1.gif]

    [image=http://www.theforce.net/swtc/Pix/kdy/blueisd2.gif]

    [image=http://www.theforce.net/swtc/Pix/kdy/blueisd3.gif]

    [image=http://www.theforce.net/swtc/Pix/kdy/blueisd4.gif]

    A chart I made to compare the Imperator-class with the Imperial II-class Star Destroyer

    [image=http://www.imagestation.com/picture/sraid27/p689ad49283d4522203e43552aa4c6289/fe1995f1.jpg.orig.jpg]
     
  2. Kier_Nimmion

    Kier_Nimmion Jedi Knight star 5

    Registered:
    Aug 9, 2000

    Star Destroyer Classes include:

    Victory-class
    Interdictor-class or Immobilzer-418
    Imperial I & II-class
    Super-class (The Executer er al.)
    Eclipse-class
    Sovereign-class

    Plus there is the Arc Hammer factory ship & Jerrec's Vegeance, both of which may be their own classes.

    Some have argued incorrectly that the Super Star Destroyer (Executer and her sister ships) is the Imperator-class, but this is wrong.

    As for Mandel's work, this is the is the first I have ever seen of them. It is not listed in any if the following boioks: 'A Guide to the Star Wars Universe', 'The Star Wars Encyclopedia', 'The Imperial Sourcebook' or 'The Essential Guide to Behicles & Vessels'.

    Basic Armament:
    [142] 38 cm Heavy Laser Batteries
    [26] 19 cm Light Laser Batteries
    [32] 60 mm Laser Cannons
    [6] forward mounted Missile Silos launching [20] ten megaton and [100] five megaton Space to Ground Missiles
    [8] rear mounted Minelayers deploying [40] two megaton Proximity Mines


    This has more fire power than an Imperial II-class, which has a total of 60 turbo laser cannons.
     
  3. RaptorRage

    RaptorRage Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 17, 2001
    Hmm I've only heard of the Imperator being argued as the class name of the ISD, rather than the SSD, but in any case, these blueprints were probably intended to represent the Star Destroyer in ANH. However it appears Mandel used earlier concept ideas when the ISD was not finalized as being a mile in length. There is a sketch in the Art of Star Wars book, that shows an early comparison chart between the ANH ships, and needless to say, the Star Destroyer sketch appears to be scaled so that the Millenium Falcon would fit snuggly into the docking bay, rather than a 150 meter Blockade Runner. What became the Blockade Runner was originally an old version of the Falcon.

    And yeah the weaponry seems to outgun the Imperial-class as listed in the WEG stats. In his illustrations, Mandel went so far as to show every turret, gun port and missile launcher to back up the data in the specifications table.

    It seems difficult to think it is large enough to carry six squadrons of TIEs, but perhaps its internal volume is geared specifically for the carrying of fighters and anti-starship weaponry. Also note there are no ground vehicles carried whatosever. This indicates a primary role geared for space combat, with its primary surface assault weaponry in the form of its Space to Ground arsenal. Perhaps its Laser Batteries have the range for an orbital bombardment as well.

    I also just considered that the Space to Ground Missiles need not necassarily be nuclear in function. The word 'megaton' is just a unit of explosive force equal to one million metric tons of TNT, but they could just be very very powerful conventional explosives rather than nukes.
     
  4. RaptorRage

    RaptorRage Jedi Master star 4

    Registered:
    Nov 17, 2001
    Lets see how the Imperator stacks up to existing RPG stats for other Star Destroyers.

    Imperator-class 486.5 meters
    142 Heavy Laser Batteries
    26 Light Laser Batteries
    32 Laser Cannons
    6 Space to Ground Missile Tubes
    8 Minelayers
    6 Starfighter Squadrons

    Victory-class 900 meters
    10 Quad Turbolaser Batteries
    40 Double Turbolaser Batteries
    80 Concussion Missile Tubes
    10 Tractor Beam Projectors
    2 Starfighter Squadrons

    Victory II-class 900 meters
    20 Turbolaser Batteries
    20 Double Turbolaser Cannons
    10 Ion Cannons
    10 Tractor Beam Projectors
    2 Starfighter Squadrons

    Imperial-class 1,600 meters
    60 Turbolaser Batteries
    60 Ion Cannons
    10 Tractor Beam Emplacements
    6 Starfighter Squadrons

    Imperial II-class 1,600 meters
    50 Heavy Turbolaser Batteries
    50 Heavy Turbolaser Cannons
    20 Ion Cannons
    10 Tractor Beam Projectors
    6 Starfighter Squadrons

    Imperial III-class 1,600 meters
    36 Double Turbolaser Cannons
    30 Turbolaser Batteries
    20 Heavy Turbolaser Cannons
    6 Concussion Missile Tubes
    50 Ion Cannons
    10 Tractor Beam Projectors
    7 Starfighter Squadrons

    Super-class 8,000 meters
    250 Turbolaser Batteries
    250 Heavy Turbolaser Batteries
    250 Concussion Missile Tubes
    250 Ion Cannons
    40 Tractor Beam Projectors
    12-14 Starfighter Squadrons

    Sovereign-class 15,000 meters
    1 Axial Superlaser
    500 Turbolaser Batteries
    500 Laser Cannons
    75 Ion Cannons
    100 Tractor Beam Projectors
    5 Gravity Well Projectors
    40 Starfighter Squadrons

    Eclipse II ~16,000 meters?
    (RPG stats unavailable)

    Eclipse 17,500 meters
    1 Axial Superlaser
    550 Turbolaser Batteries
    500 Laser Cannons
    75 Ion Cannons
    100 Tractor Beam Projectors
    10 Gravity Well Projectors
    58 Starfighter Squadrons

    "Executor-class" 17,600 meters
    (RPG stats unavailable)
     
  5. Kier_Nimmion

    Kier_Nimmion Jedi Knight star 5

    Registered:
    Aug 9, 2000
    Hmm I've only heard of the Imperator being argued as the class name of the ISD, rather than the SSD, but in any case, these blueprints were probably intended to represent the Star Destroyer in ANH.

    Last year in the lit forum someone was arguing against established fact that the Super Star Destroyer was an Imperator-class. Anyway, that's neither here nor there.

    However it appears Mandel used earlier concept ideas when the ISD was not finalized as being a mile in length. There is a sketch in the Art of Star Wars book, that shows an early comparison chart between the ANH ships, and needless to say, the Star Destroyer sketch appears to be scaled so that the Millenium Falcon would fit snuggly into the docking bay, rather than a 150 meter Blockade Runner. What became the Blockade Runner was originally an old version of the Falcon.

    That's probably it, because the Imperator doesn't look like a standard Imperial-I class seen in A New Hope.

    And yeah the weaponry seems to outgun the Imperial-class as listed in the WEG stats. In his illustrations, Mandel went so far as to show every turret, gun port and missile launcher to back up the data in the specifications table.

    The other thing I noticed is generally in Star Wars, no one uses munitions like nukes. That's not to say they don't, I think it more has to do with proton torpedos and conussion missiles, while producing a lesser yield, don't have harmful radiation. And, turbo laser batteries are orbit-to-ground if they want it.

    It seems difficult to think it is large enough to carry six squadrons of TIEs, but perhaps its internal volume is geared specifically for the carrying of fighters and anti-starship weaponry.

    I always got the impression that TIE fighters were stacked like cordwood in their launch cradles.

    Also note there are no ground vehicles carried whatosever. This indicates a primary role geared for space combat, with its primary surface assault weaponry in the form of its Space to Ground arsenal. Perhaps its Laser Batteries have the range for an orbital bombardment as well.

    Standard Star Destroyers can do orbit-to-ground with their turbo lasers.

    I also just considered that the Space to Ground Missiles need not necassarily be nuclear in function. The word 'megaton' is just a unit of explosive force equal to one million metric tons of TNT, but they could just be very very powerful conventional explosives rather than nukes.

    Agreed.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.