Who Would Win? [Version 2.0]

Who Would Win? [Version 2.0]


This thread is to bring all of the ideas of "Character X vs. Character Y" and similar subjects into one thread to discuss the topic without dealing with multiple threads.


Here is how it proceeds:


I'll begin by posting a match-up (Jango Fett vs. Mace Windu for instance) and then the next person posts a reply giving who they think would win the match-up and why, and then go on to include a new match up.

Keep in mind that is doesn't have to be good vs. bad (could be Qui Gon vs. Obi Wan) or all Star Wars (could be Mickey Mouse vs. Yoda), we're talking raw skill here, not actual situations, unless you want to include it as such (Luke vs. Wedge in X-wings or Stormtroopers vs. Clonetroopers on Geonosis).

Also, don't forget that you have to include a brief synopsis or justification of why you chose the person you posted that would win the match-up. You don't necessarily have to post the actual battle (although you can if you want ), but at least add some input of why the being would win to spark some conversation and voice your opinion.



Here goes the first one...


Qui-Gon Jinn (TPM) vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi (ANH)


Who Would Win?...


Ken Kenobi- And you have a nice day

 

qui-gon,(I think obi-wan would win if he was younger).but if they are about the same age qui-gon because he held out a long time aginst darth maul


captian panaka vs.captian typho

 

Don't we already have a thread still going
here
Who would win?
It hasn't been locked yet... .

 

well,I think this one's a little differant because you tell why they would win

 

Oh......... My bad sorry. sorry

 

Captain Panaka. Captain Typho is still young. He has alot to learn. Captain Panaka went through a war so.... he's pretty tough.


Obi-wan Kenobi (AOTC) vs. Obi-wan Kenobi (from the Jedi Apprentice Series)

 

Isn't it the mod's decision to make a 2.0 version?

 

obi anne siad it would be ok

 

Take a look at the SWC Communications thread mates.


The original "Who Would Win? thread should be locked in a bit.



Ken Kenobi- And you have a nice day

 

Nooooooo!!!!!!

I remember the very first place I had ever posted at was at the very first version of Who Would Win? Unlock it!!!!

 

obi-wan AOTC he has had alot more time to impove his skills. It's like saying padawan vs. knight because he was a padawan in the books and a kight or is it master I don't remimber in AOTC.



my favorite match up mace vs. yoda

 

Yoda because well..............





Lightsaber duel in AOTC explains all!





Han Solo VS Wedge Antilles

 

Han Solo because he is very good with a blaster and he flies the Millenium Falcon.

Obi-wan Kenobi vs. Mace Windu

 

I don't know what type of fight your taking about. In a fist fight han in a dogfight in space I don't know both great pilots but I'd have to say a tie. han is great we all know that but wedge man he and lando took down the death star. so I don't know



mace vs. Yaddle

 

Mace, they talk about him with awe and reverence in the movies, no one ever mentions Yaddle.

Ninja Jedi - Life sucks and then you die

 

MAce because he killed Jango who Obi-wan couldn't kill.


Obi-wan Kenobi vs. Mara Jade Skywalker

 

Obi Wan because he was trained by the jedi and lerned all the stuff and Mara Jade didn't




Kyle Katarn (without force powers) VS Han Solo.

 

Han Solo

Obi-Wan [ANH] vs. Dooku

 

Obi-Wan Kenobi (ANH) because he had already survived the Purge and learned much (even outside the Jedi perspective ). I'd imagine that his skills may be not as fine tuned as Dooku's, but with his prowess with the Force in the end I picture "Ol' Ben" using some special Jedi technique to take him out.

Sure, Dooku is a very accomplished swordsman and all around Force-user, but then again Ben still had the skills after all those years to use a lightsaber...that has to account for something...


Next...

Mace Windu vs. Darth Vader

Ken Kenobi- And you have a nice day

 

Vader reason is because Palpatine said that he is getting better then Master Yoda which means he can beat Mace.

Darth Sidious vs. Luke Skywalker [ROTJ]

 

I am so sad the other thread closed. Don't see the problem.

Sidious. If you take Vader out of the equation he wins easily.

Zam vs. Dengar

 

Dengar

Chewbacce Vs. Bib Fortuna, Salicous Crumb & Nien Nunb

 

chewie man all those guys are small little guys that couldn't do nothing.


IG-88 vs. Dengar

 

IG-88 would clear Dengar out, for the sole purpose that Dengar is a human and has emotions, such as pain.

IG-88, being a droid, lacks these priority weaknesses and, including its built in weapons, would easily dispose of any resistance such as that.


Next...


Anakin Skywalker (TPM) vs. Ewoks


Ken Kenobi- And you have a nice day

 

Ewoks

Tarkin vs. Nute Gunray