Why does Typho say he'd be more concerned about Padme' doing something foolish?

Any ideas?

 

Put two young adults together in a romantic setting...

I would assume he would see how Padme looked at Anakin and thought she had a crush on him. (Her family notices this too.)

 

I've often wondered that myself.

I've also wondered why een after Padme said she'd go with anakin to tatooine, he said "I'm sorry I don't have a choice!!" like he was still trying to convince her.

 

Padme's just as reckless and headstrong as Ani, and I guess Typho knew her quite well. Probably if he knew Ani too, he'd be equally concerned about both of them. Actually, he was right, as well as Obi was right about Ani.

 

I dont really think he was worried about them having sex or anything like that,it was more like him worrying about her going around away from a safe secure area and deliberatly putting herself into danger which was true because not only did she leave for Tatooine with Anakin but she told nobody about it and went to a dangerous area and also proceeds to go to Geonosis to save Obi-Wan knowing that she could be captured and enslaved or executed by the Separitists.

So Typho was right about her being foolish,put two fools together and trouble is always right around the corner.

 

Another half-baked (but potentially good) character, that doesn't come across to people on-screen.

The dialogue is as clumsy as a blaster.


If anything Mace should be concerned with putting an angst-ridden adolescent teenage Jedi (who isn't allowed to marry) with a beautiful Senator.

 

I'm not really sure why Typho says this. However, his concern is valid, as Padme is the one who convinces Anakin to go to Geonosis.

 

Good question. Typho spends a lot of time with Padme and she probably exhibits adventuristic tendences(like wanting to go to Geonosis to save Obi-Wan).

 

It serves as good foreshadowing for Padme's future decision to take off for Tatooine and Naboo. It also shows that since the Battle of Naboo in TPM, she's more willing to take risks and not go straight by the book, as she did back then.

Her tactics for winning that battle in TPM were very unconventional. Remember in the beginning of that film, she said "We must continue to rely on negotiation," a decidedly more conventional approach.

She learned that the unconventional way may sometimes be better, and has been employing those kind of tactics ever since.

 

I'm not really sure why Typho says this

Exactly, Yodajeff.

Random dialogue just keeps popping up out of nowhere.

 

A funny thing about Ani/Padmé relationship is that 99,99% of the people just see it as something that Anakin , and Anakin only, pursued relentlessly, that he forced the situation, blah, blah, blah ?
It seems nobody admits that Padmé also was interested from the begining and just playing hard to catch.
That line to me was seemed like Typho knew she had something else in mind.
You got remember that JarJar said to Anankin when he was complaining Padmé didn't remember him that since he was appointed to protect her she was the happiest as she ever been in quite a while .
Plus how i said a couple of times in the Love Story thread how stupid Padmé would be if she wore those sexy outfits in front a guy who clearly was crazy for her and expect no reaction from him ? please it was not one more plot hole .
Later she said she was dying a little every day since Anakin entered back in her life ? clear she was in love from the begining .

Only the stupid jedi missed that

 

Typho, being a good security officer has observed Padme, who is under her protection, and knows her personality. He realizes she is still young, prone to youthful flirtation and, perhaps, "forbidden love." He knows, given her personality, that she is as likely as Anakin to make the moves despite her senatorial exterior.

 

I'm not sure why you guys are having so much trouble with this line. At the end of TPM, Padme rushed headlong into danger: she may have a history of this that Typho's familiar with. At the very least, he seems to consider her a bit reckless.

 

From the novelization:

Typho: "I'd be more worried about HER doing something than him. (sigh) She's the type to GIVE orders, not take them."
Dorme: "Like-minded traveling companions."

 

Because he´d be more concerned about her doing anything! Is that hard to understand?

 

Every time I hear this line, I want to smack Typho for his ignorance. Who's the one who becomes Darth Vader here?

 

Padme is reckless, and doesn't even want to go into hiding in the first place. She's only doing it because Palpatine gave her an executive order, but Typho is scared she'll stumble head first into danger without thinking anyway.

Obi-Wan's concern has more to do with Anakin's forbidden attachment and feelings for Padme, not really physical danger.

 

I saw this line as foreshadowing asroyalguard96said.

Remember that it is Obi-Wan that he says this to, in that he would more concerned about her doing something foolish.

So who is the one who decides to take off to Geonosis to try and save Obi-Wan??!! It was Padme/Amidala.

When you really think about it, this really was a foolish thing for her to do in thinking that she and Anakin could rescue Obi-Wan.

It was not Anakin that made the decision to go, he was going follow Mace's orders.
Just a note, Anakin's reaction and words in this scene remind me of Luke's in ANH when Obi-Wan says he must learn the ways of the Force and go to Alderaan

So anyway, Typho's words about Amidala to Obi-Wan , were foreshadowing that she would be the one to do something foolish like heading off to Geonosis to try and save Obi-Wan.

Lastly, how did Amidala determine or know that the Jedi would not make it to Geonosis in enough time to save Obi-Wan? How did she know or determine that he might be killed before they arrived? Obi-Wan could have been killed before she and Anakin arrived!


Darth Sin!

 

Sin: She didn´t want to see him die for lack of her trying. That´s all there is to it!

 

"However, his concern is valid, as Padme is the one who convinces Anakin to go to Geonosis. "

Pretty much sums it up. She's not the most rational person.

 

Why does Typho say he'd be more concerned about Padme' doing something foolish?

Maybe she's fallen in love with other mass-murderers before...

 

So that explains why things didn't work out between her and Palo.

 

I thought this thing would be on page 45 by now.

 

What happened to Captain Panaka? Why was he replaced by Typho??

 

Panaka is probably on Queen Jamilla's staff... Just because Padme has a different position, it doesn't mean the entire staff gets rearranged to accomadate her.