Saga Lightsaber Duels We Wish We Would Have Seen in the Movies

I think I'll actually go with the apprentices on this one. Sidious can obviously defeat Dooku 1 on 1 but Dooku held up against Yoda pretty well so he's not too far behind. Adding Maul into the mix puts the apprentices over the top.

Next battle...


Acklay (AOTC)

vs


Wampa (ESB)

 

Acklay, Size difference would be the biggest Factor, the Wampa doesn't look to Agile either to dodge the Acklay's Stabby Legs.



VS



10x Jedi Younglings vs 10x Ewok warriors.

 

I would assume the Younglings have lightsabers, if so, they win.

No lightsabers and the Ewoks win.

Another monster battle.


Rancor (ROTJ)

vs


Krayt Dragon (bones seen in ANH)

 

Rancor, From that Picture the Krayt Dragon doesn't look big enough to pose a threat to it.



Finn With a Lightsaber

vs



a Jedi Youngling.

 

As far as lightsaber duels, I think General Grievous vs. Obi-Wan would have...could have...been outstanding. Dare I say, epic.

But, alas...

 

I'm confused....They did have a lightsaber duel??????

also the point of the Thread is to answer the Poster's above scenario with a winner and why, then post your own.

Any Duels you'd like to have seen?

 

Youngling due to the force.

I don't remember if this one has been done but how about...


Darth Vader - pre-suit - ROTS timeframe

vs


Darth Vader - suit - ANH timeframe

 

Admittedly, I was just being snarky; as I personally found that whatever it was that occurred between Grievous and OBK was farcical at best.

 

I don't think so.....hmmm It's a tough one......Physically RotS is stronger and probably stronger in the force, But Vader more immersed in the Dark Side and more experienced..... But i think overall Anakin RotS wins......



Qui Gonn


Vs




That which some may consider he was responsible for creating.....Darth Vader

 

I think Vader would slice and dice Qui Gonn. Vader wins...

Monster battle...


Acklay (AOTC)

vs


Krayt Dragon (bones seen in ANH)

 

Mace vs Anakin could have possibly worked.

 

Krayt Dragon all the way.


Okay, now...

RotS Sidious

vs.

Valkorion (Eternal Emperor)

 

Sidious wins, because I don't know who that other guy is. (and Sidious was one of the most powerful force users in the history of the galaxy)

Rebels Ahsoka Tano

vs

end of TFA Rey (without any Luke training)

 

Ahsoka Tano would wipe the floor with her

Pong Krell Vs General Grievous

 

That would be a crazy duel. So many lightsabers spinning and clashing. Guess I'd give the edge to Grievous.

Mace Windu vs Darth Maul/Savage Oppress

 

Sidious beat Maul and Oppress, so I think Windu would as well, although he might have a more difficult go of it.


Hypothetical:
Dark side Yoda (in his prime)
vs
Light side Palpaine (in his prime)

 

I'd have to go with dark side Yoda. More experience and the dark side does seem to give a bit of an edge.

More monsters...


Krayt Dragon (bones seen in ANH)

vs


Boga (the thing Obi-Wan was riding in ROTS)

 

Krayt Dragon

I remember reading a passage from Dark Rendevous, where Dooku tried to convince Yoda to turn to the Dark Side, and he saw a vision if Yoda were a Sith, he would utterly destroy Sidious.

Rey, Finn, and Kylo(all with sabers)

vs.

AOTC Anakin

 

is Rey Post awakening and Kylo uninjured? If so it would be very close. AotC Anakin was made to look like a litte female dog by Dooku. I think Finn would be the first to fall, wouldn't stand much chance, Rey and Kylo would pose a bigger threat, But due to lack of Rey's Training, she's the next to go, Then It's Grandfather vs Grandson. Anakin would be somewhat tired at this point after fighting 3 people, So Kylo may just edge him out and Win.

If it's Rey pre-awakening, then Anakin wins as he'd dispatch Finn and Rey in mere moments.


Kylo Ren

vs



ESB Luke

 

Luke had more experience at this point than Rey did so Luke could win. But assuming Kylo is uninjured and at 100% he should win... He'd simply have way more experience than Luke at that point.

Next Battle. Pre-suit Vader vs everybody who touches a lightsaber or lightsaber type weapon in TFA:


Darth Vader (pre-suit)

vs


Kylo Ren (uninjured), Rey (awakened), Finn, TR-8R

 

ooo Tough one, Basically Anakin would pretty much insta-kill Finn, Then he's left with Kylo, Rey and TR-8R. Though TR-8R sits out, he doesn't want to fight along side a Traitor or those that are friends with a Traitor, Anakin dispatches Rey and then eventually over-whelms Kylo.....Then TR-8R gets up, Cracks his knuckles, fires up the Baton and goes to town on Anakin, Despite being the chosen one, having the highest midichlorian count, years of Combat training and being a veteran of the Clone Wars, He's simply not match for TR-8R's Sick Spins. TR-8R is the Victor!!!





Pre-Suit Vader

Vs



100x Younglings.

 

That's a little tough because Younglings could mean 6 year-olds or teenagers on the cusp of being Padawans. My instinct would say that Vader would win, but if a lot of the younglings are 11 or 12 years old, he would probably be tired after wiping them all out.

Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, and Saesee Tinn vs. Darth Vader (ESB)

 

I'll go with Vader. The ease at which Sidious took them out makes me believe that Vader would win. Although Fisto might put up a good fight.

Next Battle...The council sends two different jedi to Naboo...


Darth Maul

vs


Ki-Adi-Mundi & Kitt Fisto

 

I'd go with Maul, I believe Qui Gon and TPM Obi-Wan are better Duelists than both Kit Fisto and Ki-Adi, Maul kills Qui-Gon, not really breaking much of a Sweat and really manages to defeat Obi-Wan, Just underestimated him at the end. So Maul would kill them both, maybe break a little bit of a sweat



vs

+
Darth Maul and RotS Obi-Wan

 

I think if Dooku can use the force to take Obi-Wan out of the fight then surely Yoda can. So I see it going down that way. Yoda uses the force to throw Obi-Wan across the room then deals with Maul. Yoda eventually defeats Maul then defeats Obi-Wan.

How about...


Yoda

vs


Dooku and Maul