It is an interesting read, and I wish there were more like that, cause I don't think what everyone says is an exact science, but it is still a good read. I look at it this way, she aint gonna be a diehard like we are. Whatever anyone wants to say about the saga, 1-6 or 4-6,1-3, there is always one of the 6 SW movies that sucks us into being a fan. For me, it was Star Wars in '77, and cause I love that movie so much, the rest is just gravy for me, but the original SW is the reason why I am a SW fan, that movie is my favorite of any movie I have ever seen. For many of my friends, it is ESB that made them fans, they just love Vader in that movie, and although they think ANH is a classic, ESB is what sold them as fans. For the PT, I have read many here that AOTC is what sold them to SW. They mention that they liked TPM, but AOTC solidified their love for the rest of the saga. What I am getting at, is whatever way you watch it, to be a diehard fan who watches these movies over and over and over since we first saw them, you have to love one, some, or all the movies. After reading her assessment, I think she liked em, but didn't love em, and to me, she aint gonna be a crazy SW fan like we are. I highly doubt she will be watching any of the 6 SW movies hundreds of times through her life, and I think everyone of us here has done that. Thats what makes us SW fans, the replay value, and never getting sick of them.