Lit Biggest unsolved mysteries in Legends or Canon?

I have already shown you some evidence, now it is time for you to tell me how you fix the TCW continuity errors in Clone Wars Multimedia Project spoiler alert it would still make no sense ROTS novel and Republic comics does not deserve to be Retcon in the EU Timeline just for TCW as i said before you want TCW? just follow the Disney Universe in there TCW is more important also the EU is not longer continued why should i care for what Lucasfilm said in the last days of the EU but well, some fans defend some contradictions made by Disney in their own novels the EU is not coming back so i say believe what you want to believe but for me TCW is not canon in the EU

 

You keep saying it makes no sense but haven’t given a specific example of a contradiction you think is too difficult to resolve. AFAIK the biggest is contradictory timelines but that’s easy enough to change. I don’t think the fact that Ahsoka isn’t mentioned or doesn’t appear in certain stories is a contradiction of its own, but some people cite it as one

 

Read the Clone Wars Multimedia Project and watch TCW and then you will realize that there are many contradictions
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Clone_Wars_multimedia_project

 

I read and watched both and whenever I noticed a contradiction I either came up with a headcanon or lucasfilm did it officially with a retcon. For example that article says Ventress was introduced in the clone wars with a completely different backstory. But that backstory can be reconciled with the Republic comics and the clone wars micro series. At the most the story group said to disregard parts of a comic, but they didn’t erase anything from continuity entirely the parts that still work happened

 

The EU was riddled with contradictions, that’s nothing new. Ask any fan of Boba Fett. Just because a writer later comes along and hastily uses retroactive continuity to try and make sense of those contradictions doesn’t change that fact.

 

Boba Fett in the EU had satisfyingly well made retcons like the Mandalorian fighting during the Clone Wars in the original Marvel Comics was in reality Spar not Boba and Jaster Mereel name was an alias that Boba Fett used in honor of Jango's mentor now tell me what retcons TCW did to satisfactorily fit with Clone Wars Multimedia Project? TCW did forced retcons that you simply had to accept because Lucasfilm wanted TCW to have the same level of importance as the movies no matter that it contradicts most of the Clone Wars Multimedia Project stories i prefer to have the ROTS novel and all the arcs of Republic comics than to stay with TCW in the EU continuity the Disney Universe had a different version of Luke fate a different Han and Leia kid why can't the EU have a different version of the Clone Wars era?

 

It doesn’t matter if you found the Jaster Mereel retcon to be satisfying, it’s still a masssive contradiction and example of retroactive continuity. The EU is littered with other instances of that, it doesn’t change those stories nature as being part of the EU.

 

You still haven't told me how you would solve the contradictions that TCW caused with the Clone Wars Multimedia Project but well Lucasfilm now considers the Disney ST as canon movies that Lucas never made no matter how much Leland Chee tried to maintain continuity, he was still a Lucasfilm employee and had to say yes to everything it's funny how Dave Filoni is now contradicting Disney novels and comics as he did with Clone Wars Multimedia Project but there are still fans who continue to defend him Lucasfilm now considers the Kenobi show as canon show that contradicts ANH, it was obvious that Lucas wanted Obi Wan and Vader not to see each other again until ANH, but Disney doesn't care about breaking movies canon, so if Lucasfilm can break movies canon, it is obvious that they would accept TCW contradictions with the Clone Wars Multimedia Project

 

Yes the clone wars era needed the most retcons out of any era in legends, in no small part due to TCW, and yes TCW officially is canon to the legends timeline. If you prefer the CWMMP as it was prior to the retcons that came as a result of TCW, just do what I do and headcanon TCW into the s-canon tier, or out of legends entirely. This argument has become very redundant, and it’s getting annoying

 

No. Just no they are not. Abel is a random force monster (no different from Waru) that Denning ties into a couple throwaway episodes of a dumb kids show (that was implied to be metaphysical anyaway and no one remembers after it). It is not essential, it is a peripherally story.

The NJO is an essential story.

 

I feel like I have PTSD from that still.

 

If you're going to consider "something I assume GL would have wanted but wasn't honored by later projects" a contradiction, then I don't see how there's much more discussion to be had about it. The entirety of both canon and Legends pretty much collapses right then and there, doesn't it? Although the number of times GL contradicted himself by that standard might be amusing to consider.

 

But they aren't punished, at least not in LotF, Han even says "give her a chance". It's not until FotJ that Daala stops obeying the jedi, I mean becomes an issue.

 

The idea that Ahsoka Tano exists in the EU and lives in the same universe as Kyle Katarn, Jacen and Jaina Solo, Lumiya, Kyp Durron seems very fan fictionish to me Ahsoka feels more like a modern character and i feel like she doesn't fit with the old classic Star Wars Universe the EU you still haven't told me how you would justify the contradictions of TCW, the current Lucasfilm will never do it because they don't care about the EU

 

Yeah, yeah. Let's move on.

 

Nashira...

We all know she was NOT Luke's mom, but someone from Akanah's life, but why did she pick her name out of all possible ones for her fake story? Maybe there was more to her than meets the eye and some truth in the lie?

At least to me that is still an open mystery. Who could she be, especially if NOT Padmé under an alias, nor any handmaiden as we know their fates by now (especially in OneCanon).

Nashira means "bearer of good news" in arabic as per etymology. And Wialu told Luke that Leia would have a place amongst the White Current Fallanassi if she ever so chose to come. Was that a prophecy? Why Leia? Luke did not meet their criteria, we know. And instead of Leia later Jacen would come and take up that offer in her stead but without the intent to stay, lieing about that part to get admitted even, which shows how offbalance he already was before he joined them.

So regarding Wialu's offer I wonder if her offer could be connected to Nashira and her secret identity after all and a legacy the Skysolos have with the White Current unknown to them.

While Padmé and Handmaidens are ruled out, there may yet be someone to meet the criteria.

Maybe a handmaiden from outside the core cadre that formed the Amidalans? Given the EU had many more named than just them.
Maybe a relative of Padmé on the Naberrie side?
Maybe even someone from Shmi Skywalkers family before she got taken by pirates and sold into slavery.

 

I've always wondered about Nashira, too, and it was a shame that it didn't actually get connected to Padme in some roundabout way.

I still remember reading the back-cover blurb from Before The Storm in my 15-year-old naivete and actually thinking we were going to learn more about Luke and Leia's mother, when Episode I itself was still a good three years away. Ah, youth. I think the Black Fleet Crisis is among the most underrated of all of Legends and I love the trilogy to death for various reasons, but the "gotcha" of Nashira -- plus Akanah's whole attitude towards Luke -- is the one aspect of the trilogy that still doesn't sit well with me, even after more than a few re-reads through the decades.

 

Did Sate Pestage and Kinman Doriana exists in Disney Canon? imagine both being part of the First Order and Sith Eternal in the EU Sate Pestage helped Palpatine Dark Empire

What about Mara Jade she existed in Disney Canon or not?

 

Sate Pestage exists in canon, Kinman and Mara do not as yet.

 

Biggest is still in canon, the Syfo Dyas mystery. His death, how he he got enough funds to order an army of clones. Him and Dooku working together before Dooku Kills him.

 

Whatever happened to the Neo-separatist Union, Confederacy of Corporate Systems, and the Sovereign Lattitudes of Excessive Eloquenc.

 

What color lightsabers did the characters in Dark Empire actually use?

 

Sickly green.