For those who have seen it: How do you rate Attack of the Clones?

I'd almost vote the bottom one if it was about FOTR. As for AOTC, I'll tell you on thursday.

 

By the way, anyone who claims that they fell asleep watching AOTC is getting IP banned.

 

Maybe I will. Regular users, feel free to take note of how much time cbjedi spends here after May 16th, and draw your own conclusions

 

I just couldn't believe how excited I was in there. Much more so than TPM and my build up this time was considerably less. I absolutely loved it.

 

One of the best films of the year, to be certain.

Best ever? I'll have to see it a few more times to see how it stacks up after multiple viewings.

 

I voted it as one of the best movies of all time. Because it is.

RB

 

One of the best of all time period!

 

Not as good as ANH or ESB in my books, but better than ROTJ and WAY better than TPM.

 

it's my new favorite star wars film. i think it beats esb even... it was pure magic!!

thank you george!! i haven't fealt like i did last night since i was a kid. you've got your old groove back flanneled one!!

hehehe! great film! can't wait to see it again today.

 

I don't know if it's the best movie of all time because it's kind of difficult to compare Star Wars with the likes of say The Godfather or the Shawshank Redemption. As far as action movies go, it is definately one if not the best ever. Without doubt it is the best Star Wars movie.

 

Amazing. Simply Amazing.

Amazing.

 

I must have seen a different movie than everyone else. I voted for awful, though with a couple redeeming qualities.

 

Hey who voted for the last one anyway?

I thought is was completely awesome!!! It met and exceeded my expectations.

 

It rocked!!!!!!

One the greatest movies I've ever seen

 

Binary_Sunset, are you insane? I used to respect your opinions, but now it seems to me that they are clouded by some irrational prejudice against the prequels. I bet you deliberately went into this movie with the determination that you were not going to enjoy it. I hope I am wrong. I can understand you not thinking it was not one of the best movies of all time, but to say it is awful is just ludicrous.

 

Loved it. One of the best all time ST films ever. I still love ROTJ though! But over all AOTC rocked!!!

 

Wow, the eternal cynic himself, barnsthefatjedi even loved it, and for once, I have to agree with him.

 

Crap, I wasn't supposed to post under that sock.

 

Better than TPM, ANH.
Ties with ROTJ
Not as good as ESB


for the rest, see the sig.

 

Luckily, I had my friends to keep waking me up.

I voted for the one above it; it seemed lonely with no votes.

1% is better than 1% with no votes.

Am I about to get IP banned?

 

Wonderful movie. Ranks in the middle for me: below ESB and ANH but above ROTJ and TPM. It will be hard to find another movie this year as good as this one.

 

A week or so ago, I wasn't even planning to see it in the threatre.

I just walked out of that theatre a few minutes ago, knowing I had witnessed an amazing film.

Move over ESB. The King is here.

 

The movie totally blew me away and I really can't wait to see it again. I can definately say that it ranks up there as one of the best Star Wars movies.

 

The movie is simply a classic in my mind. I've read some basher's opinions, although I respect them, they're very much futile in my point of view.

Here's how I rank the films now, out of 4...

1. The Empire Strikes Back ****
2. Attack of the Clones ***½
3. A New Hope ***½
4. Return of the Jedi ***
5. The Phantom Menace ***