PT The "What-If?" Depository - ALL conceptual/hypothetical conversation goes here

He was actually stifling a cough because a fly had just flown into his mouth at that moment.

 

It wasn't a fly; it was a baby Geonosian.

 

He wants to make babies with Padme...

[slaps hands together like a seal] Funnnneeeeeeeee!!!

 

So he's now pregnant?

 

Isn't Anakin supposed to be more powerful than anyone else? Only his ability to channel his powers is questionable, due to lack of experience in controlling his emotions?

 

He is, but because he's so wild and out of control that for all his powers, it's wasted. He's more BANG BANG BANG SMASH rather than keeping calm, controlled, and focused. Only then would he have been powerful.

Yoda would've demolished Anakin, no question about that. As far as he's concerned (from what I remember) Anakin had always been this unwanted child forced into the Jedi Academy by the dying wishes of Qui-Gon. Way this would turn out, Yoda would be fixing what he thought was a mistake he had made 13 years ago: allowing the wisdom of a dying knight and his headstrong apprentice overshadow his own, the centuries-old Grandmaster Jedi.

Obi-Wan against Palpatine? I fear it'd be the exact opposite. We see how well Obi-Wan faired against Dooku, haven't we? Obi-Wan would've been slaughtered, and it would be Yoda and the two twins versus a very powerful Sith Lord.

Could make for an interesting AU fiction.

 

Hahaha, who thinks like this.

Sent from my GT-S5660 using Tapatalk 2

 

"hey you can't do that!

lock this thread...or something"

 

He has a higher midichlorian count but that isn't necessarily the same thing as realized power.

 

Some fans like to overanalyze.

 

Well, the dark side endings in these types of games are just what-if tales. Not meant to be taken seriously.

He has the potential to be that powerful, but he's still a ways off mentally. Something that doesn't come until after he's been Vader for a while. Hence he's able to fight Obi-wan and not make the mistakes that he had made before. Hence killing those that he did during the dark times. Hence holding his **** together while fighting Luke until he got hit in the shoulder. You also have to understand that Palpatine is also talking about the dark side of the Force giving Vader unlimited power, once he has achieved mastery of the Sith teachings. Anakin only has knowledge of the Jedi Arts and to the Sith, that is limiting his true potential. If Anakin hadn't be so emotionally compromised in the hallway when Palpatine revealed himself, it would be a whole different ballgame.

 

It actually does look like that.

 

Well, I usually assume them to be at least possible, as in the case of, for example, TFU 2 but in this case I'm not so certain.

 

I know right? Or maybe his rubber mask was falling off?

 

Patience, Merkual. Patience. It will die.

 

Let me get on topic and give an actual answer. He wanted her dead and that scratch made her one step closer to being dead.

 

It's going to come out Alien-style.

 

But these are kids movies!

 

OMG - I threw up a little bit in my mouth..... and (if possible) laughed out loud at the same time....

 

Spaceballs-style then?

 

Hmmm I suppose so.

 

Hello my honey, hello my baby...hello Natalie Portmannnnn!

 

I always assumed that what the videogame alternate ending implied, is Vader got such a rush from killing Obi-wan, in that uncompromised and focused state he could easilier kill Sidious. Just a thought.

 

With TFU and its sequel, we know the correct endings based on the novelizations. ROTS, well, I don't have to go there.