Grey 1, It's not a fake. You're underestimating the power that Harry already has. He has little to gain from posting a fake and even more to lose. He already has a huge following and studios already take him very seriously (he was named one of the 50 or 100 most influential people in Hollywood by some reputable publication). If he posted a fake review, he stands to lose the clout he has successfully gained over the past few years. He might post fake reviews from time to time from his various sources, but anything that comes directly from him or the other main contributors of his site are absolutely reliable. I would take his review with a grain of salt, because he does tend to go way overboard with the praise or criticism, but I have no doubt in my mind that he saw a rough cut. The only question is whether Lucasfilm intentionally leaked the film to him or if it was indeed a true leak. It would make perfect sense for Lucasfilm to leak it to him. There is relatively zero hype for this film compared to TPM, and this would be a great ploy to start generating hype. Fans will be more resistant to Lucasfilm-generated hype, so going through AICN is a great strategy to generate "grass roots" hype. Also, it would make more sense to leak it a non-exclusive Star Wars fan site to give it even more credibility, and because Harry is such a huge Star Wars fan and Lucas worshipper, there was no way he would give it anything but a glowing review.