Discussion in 'The Phantom Menace' started by Heavenly_Angel, Apr 29, 2003.
what was your first impression on the movie?
I thought it was great!
I was amazed at how well the digital characters were realized.
On a technical level, Jar Jar was amazing.
complete awe and overwhelmment. It was almost like a sensual overload--the sights and sounds were layered on so densely, i had never seen anything quite like it. The only other film to do that to me was the Matrix a few months later.
I loved it. It reawakened my love for Star Wars.
It was neither love or hate. I attribute that to not exactly knowing what to expect and then getting something I could never have fully imagined in my own head. I knew most major plot details beforehand thanks to my weakness for spoilers then - not this time though . It was just a lot to take in. It was Star Wars, but not from the angle we had seen Star Wars before. I've come to appreciate this different angle.
The end duel was exhilarating. Since it was the last part of the film, it stayed on my mind the most. Once the geek inside of me got over the awesome duel, I could start paying more attention and enjoying the beauty of the rest of the film.
I was virtually spoiler free for Episode I. I think the only thing I knew beforehand was that Yoda and Jabba and a young Anakin were going to be in it. I had absolutely no idea what to expect.
I left the theater and felt disappointed the entire drive home.
It's gotten a little better over time, not much but a little. I am still lukewarm (no pun intended) to it.
Being spoiler-free had the reverse affect on me. I absolutley loved it and I think one of the reasons why I enjoyed it so much . I did not have my hopes up to high, and was able to watch the movie without being dissapointed at all.
I was shocked and awed. So much so that I went to see it "several" more times.
I loved it. I thought it was a great addition to the Star Wars universe.
to follow up to what others have said:
once i got over the initial sensual shock and had time to actually reflect on the susbstance of the film, i realized it was nothing AT ALL like what i was expecting. I was completly spoiler-free--the only thing i had seen was the trailers (but one thing that always bugged me was that the soundtrack gave away Qui Gons death! argh!). And from the trailers the film looked a lot more darker and mysterious. I expected it to be darker and forboding, the way episode II was. It wasnt at all like star wars, both in terms of story, characters, plot, visuals or design. It was a completly different style, but whatever the style, i loved it and thought it really gave the impression of a whole different era than the PT.
And i actually thought Jar Jar was pretty funny most the time. still do.
Only *very* mild disapointments--Darth Maul and Obi Wan could have used more screen time, and Jake Lloyd was a pretty bad actor.
I thought it was great, and time has not dampened my enthusiasm.
I don't know why Jake is picked on so much, I think he did pretty good for an 9-year old and couldn't expect much more from him.
Actually, for a while, I was of the opinion that his acting was bad (mainly due to people pointing it out) but the last time I watched it I just realized , hey, this kid aint so bad.
I loved it! And I loved it just as much the next 6 times I watched it in the theater and every time after that on VHS and later DVD.
I thought it was awsome; especially the Duel-Of-Fates scene (watching Darth Maul out class those two jedi was fun to watch.)
what was your first reaction when you first saw TPM?
Oh the intensity!
I hated it but over time I have come to like it. I think my expectations were too high.
I loved it the first time. Next showing on the same day, I said to myself "Man, is it just me, or does a lot of this dialogue suck?". Third viewing, next day: "Yeah, a lot of this dialogue definitely sucks".
My opinion now: Disappointing, but still a good film, even if it does have a lot of problems. 7/10
I went with my dad. As we walked out of the theatre, I was completely silent - then we got into the car, and my dad asked me, "So, what did you think?"
I stared at him, totally stupified. I couldn't put how much I loved it into words. I just grinned.
My initial reaction was positive, although it was well past midnight, so my head wasn't thinking quite right.
I loved it!! I still love it.
But I didn't have the same feeling with AOTC. I was depressed after AOTC, I didn't know what to think.
I went to a 1am showing and I came out nearer half 3, wanting to go straight back in. Any minor flaws were overwhelmed by how awesome some of the scenes were. The pod-race was absolutely stunning and I didn't think it could be topped, however, the saber battle did just that and its never lost any of its impact to this day.
I was totally overwhelmed! There was so much going on, with Palpatine, Sidious, Anakin and his mother, Qui-Gon, Watto, the sea monsters, the pod race, the senate.... [face_shocked] !!!!
I thought the OT was slightly better though and Jar Jar felt somewhat out of place. He was like the typical actionmovie sidekick of the nineties.
Boy, has my view changed!
Oh, and for the longest time I was also of the opinion that Obi-Wan shouldÂ´ve had a bigger role, but I donÂ´t think thatÂ´s needed anymore. Could have something to do with realising that there were two more episodes to go....
I was blown away by the film. And I had to go to the bathroom really bad.
Mixed. I saw it five times in the theatre.
The good parts stayed good, but the boring parts became unbearable by the 5th time.
Have the DVD and watch it about once or twice a year.
From the beginning however, the film was, and still remains, a visual masterpiece.
The music is great too although the editing butchers it somewhat, especially at the end.
Loved the politics and Palpy's character from the first.
Was in AWE at the Senate scene. Later became bugged at the damn flying droids. Pointless effects combined with seamless ones.